When Will We See Freshmen Ratings?

[GatorBait]

Quote: Originally Posted by BayBomber49

BTW, from what I hear, EA sports has left out Illini FR QB Isiah "Juice" Williams out of the game. He was the #5 QB in the class and has been heralded as the QB with the most potential and bar-none best arm in this class. How can EA leave him out?

EA has made some head scratching mistakes with freshman this year. Not having Juice in the game is a huge mistake. Also, EA rated Running Backs Demarco Murray and James Aldridge higher than Chris Wells (the #1 RB on both Scout and Rivals).

[mcculac]

pulled from another board:

Top Freshman

* 1. SS #3, Florida St, 87 OVR - spd 91, str 70, awr 65, agi 95, acc 94, cth 70, car 78, jmp 91, bkt 78, tak 76, pbk 52, rbk 56, sta 95, inj 97

2. HB #29, Oklahoma, 85 OVR - spd 95, str 65, awr 48, agi 95, acc 96, cth 76, car 85, jmp 84, bkt 84, tak 52, pbk 48, rbk 44, sta 94, inj 90

3. WR #85, Florida, 85 OVR - spd 96, str 52, awr 62, agi 98, acc 98, cth 87, car 65, jmp 91, btk 52, tak 52, rbk 48, sta 96, inj 94

4. HB #34, Notre Dame, 84 OVR - spd 92, str 76, awr 52, agi 87, acc 94, cth 68, car 65, jmp 74, btk 90, tak 48, pbk 48, rbk 44, sta 88, inj 90

5. HB #28, Ohio St, 84 OVR - spd 87, str 76, awr 52, agi 88, acc 90, cth 68, car 90, jmp 74, btk 90, tak 59, pbk 48, rbk 52, sta 84, inj 90

6. HB #13, USC, 84 OVR - spd 92, str 74, awr 44, agi 91, acc 93, cth 72, car 85, jmp 82, btk 86, tak 72, pbk 48, rbk 44, sta 87, inj 92

7. LE #55, Louisville, 84 OVR - spd 85, str 76, awr 44, agi 84, acc 88, cth 62, car 44, jmp 74, btk 56, tak 72, pbk 48, rbk 52, sta 82, inj 88

8. HB #24, Clemson, 84 OVR - spd 95, str 62, awr 70, agi 96, acc 97, cth 74, car 76, jmp 76, btk 74, tak 44, pbk 44, sta 95, inj 88

9. QB #15, Florida, 84 OVR - spd 74, str 62, awr 62, agi 78, acc 82, cth 44, car 68, jmp 70, btk 59, tak 52, thp 90, tha 90, sta 96, inj 94

10. SS #38, Ole Miss, 84 OVR - spd 89, str 74, awr 56, agi 91, acc 91, cth 65, car 68, jmp 93, btk 68, tak 85, pbk 52, rbk 56, sta 92, inj 91

11. LE #98, Georgia, 84 OVR - spd 82, str 76, awr 44, agi 82, acc 84, cth 62, car 68, jmp 72, btk 76, tak 78, pbk 48, rbk 52, sta 86, inj 87


12-25 are all rated 82 OVR

* 12. ROLB #2, Texas
13. QB #7, Texas
14. LE #99, Texas
15. RE #83, Ohio St
16. FS #46, USC
17. RE #45, Maryland
18. WR #81, USC
19. HB #35, Florida St
20. HB #21, Miami
21. C #57, Oregon St
22. MLB #55, Kentucky
23. TE #85, Florida St
24. RE #60, Clemson
25. HB #44, Auburn

[randyf]

those ratings don't make much sense to me FSU got 1 RB and he was a 2 star according to scout.com why would he be the 19th best player in the nation. I don't know why Myron Rolle should get an 87 OVR that is too high for any freshman, according to rivals he wasn't even a top 10 player, Harvin was #1. Mustain was regarded by every recruiting service in the nation as the number 1 QB and he isnt in the top 25? These can't be right at all, I thought Whipsmart said that Tebow was an 85 and so was Mustain

[theaub]

Quote: Originally Posted by randyf

those ratings don't make much sense to me FSU got 1 RB and he was a 2 star according to scout.com why would he be the 19th best player in the nation. I don't know why Myron Rolle should get an 87 OVR that is too high for any freshman, according to rivals he wasn't even a top 10 player, Harvin was #1. Mustain was regarded by every recruiting service in the nation as the number 1 QB and he isnt in the top 25? These can't be right at all, I thought Whipsmart said that Tebow was an 85 and so was Mustain

Current-gen and 360 ratings are different.

[AuburnAlumni]

Where is Andre Smith, OL Bama?

This guy is regarded as the next Orlando Pace. Even though he's a Bammer..the kid should be a top 5 Frosh ratings wise.

[Nivek]

Quote: Originally Posted by GatorBait

Rolle can't check Harvin. Never has, never will be.

LMAO!

[theaub]

Yeah...Smith and Mustain not on this list is weird...not to mention that #35 on FSU's website is a senior fullback.

[SuperBowlNachos]

How is Matt Stafford not atleast an 82 ovr?. He was the #1 QB on Rivals and #2 on Scout

I'm Real suprised Mustain and Stafford were left off but Jevan Snead is an 82.