Top 25 WR's

[Beantown]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

Sadly, I do play better when I just close my eyes and start hitting buttons.

I'm just going to have to be Notre Dame and use their super offense to my advantage.

[OSUG1]

Woods at 19

probably the only Cowboy to be ranked in a Top 25.

[MassNole]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

I am sure you probably think so.

The kid averaged over 20 yards a catch and tied the FSU record for receiving TDs by a freshman, he is a much better player than most of that list, most namely Ryan Moore of Miami who is just pure crap of a player.

Also, where in the world is Derrick Williams of Penn State? He too is a much greater talent than 2/3 of that list. What is EA's obsession with vastly overrating non-BCS players this year.

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by MassNole

The kid averaged over 20 yards a catch and tied the FSU record for receiving TDs by a freshman, he is a much better player than most of that list, most namely Ryan Moore of Miami who is just pure crap of a player. Also, where in the world is Derrick Williams of Penn State? He too is a much greater talent than 2/3 of that list. What is EA's obsession with vastly overrating non-BCS players this year.

Alrighty then.

[coogrfan]

Phil Steele's top 25 wrs

1. Calvin Johnson- GT
2. Dwayne Jarrett- USC
3. Jeff Samardzija- ND
4. Ted Ginn Jr. - OSU
5. Jarrett Hicks- Texas Tech
6. Jason Hill- Wash. St.
7. Steve Smith- USC
8. Sidney Rice- S. Carolina
9. Marcus Monk- Arkansas
10. Todd Blythe- Iowa St.
11. James Hardy- IU
12. Dwayne Bowe- LSU
13. Robert Meachem- Tenn.
14. Derrick Williams- Penn St.
15. Courtney Taylor- Auburn
16. Greg Carr- Fla. St.
17. Ernie Wheelwright- Minn
18. Dorien Bryant- Purdue
19. Mario Urrutia- Louisville
20. Mario Manningham- Michigan
21. Chansi Stuckey- Clemson
22. Lance Leggett- Miami
23. D'Juan Woods- Ok. St.
24. Malcolm Kelly- Oklahoma
25. Limas Sweed- Texas

[aps22]

Where is Derrick Williams, Jordan Norwood, and Deon Butler. EA really screwed PSU with this list. Those 3 are definately better than half the list.

[MassNole]

Seriously, wtf is Rhema McKnight doing there? His career high is 610 yards in a season and he is coming off of an injury and a total of 5 catches. I know EA wants Notre Dame to be amazing, they always do, but this is just ridiculous!

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by coogrfan

Phil Steele's top 25 wrs Calvin Johnson- GT Dwayne Jarrett- USC Jeff Samardzija- ND Ted Ginn Jr. - OSU Jarrett Hicks- Texas Tech Jason Hill- Wash. St. Steve Smith- USC Sidney Rice- S. Carolina Marcus Monk- Arkansas Todd Blythe- Iowa St. James Hardy- IU Dwayne Bowe- LSU Robert Meachem- Tenn. Derrick Williams- Penn St. Courtney Taylor- Auburn Greg Carr- Fla. St. Ernie Wheelwright- Minn Dorien Bryant- Purdue Mario Urrutia- Louisville Mario Manningham- Michigan Chansi Stuckey- Clemson Lance Leggett- Miami D'Juan Woods- Ok. St. Malcolm Kelly- Oklahoma Limas Sweed- Texas

Interesting list, not one non-BCS player on it. Not that I really like Steele that much.

The two names that were left off the EA list that raised an eybrow for me, wre Bowe of LSU, whom I think is a better player than Doucet, and Urrutia from Louisville.