Top 25 WR's

[Cebby]

Quote: Originally Posted by MassNole

Seriously, wtf is Rhema McKnight doing there? His career high is 610 yards in a season and he is coming off of an injury and a total of 5 catches. I know EA wants Notre Dame to be amazing, they always do, but this is just ridiculous!

Says the guy who just complained that a guy with a career high of 614 yards isn't on there at about 10-12.

[aps22]

Quote: Originally Posted by MassNole

Seriously, wtf is Rhema McKnight doing there? His career high is 610 yards in a season and he is coming off of an injury and a total of 5 catches. I know EA wants Notre Dame to be amazing, they always do, but this is just ridiculous!

I agree, this is frikkin rediculous. I hate ND

[MassNole]

Quote: Originally Posted by coogrfan

Phil Steele's top 25 wrs Calvin Johnson- GT Dwayne Jarrett- USC Jeff Samardzija- ND Ted Ginn Jr. - OSU Jarrett Hicks- Texas Tech Jason Hill- Wash. St. Steve Smith- USC Sidney Rice- S. Carolina Marcus Monk- Arkansas Todd Blythe- Iowa St. James Hardy- IU Dwayne Bowe- LSU Robert Meachem- Tenn. Derrick Williams- Penn St. Courtney Taylor- Auburn Greg Carr- Fla. St. Ernie Wheelwright- Minn Dorien Bryant- Purdue Mario Urrutia- Louisville Mario Manningham- Michigan Chansi Stuckey- Clemson Lance Leggett- Miami D'Juan Woods- Ok. St. Malcolm Kelly- Oklahoma Limas Sweed- Texas

That list actually looks pretty damned good to me, definitely vastly superior to what EA put out. I'd rate Chansi Stuckey a little higher, probably around 11-12 and move everyone else down accordingly. I am sure most UM fans agree Leggett is much better than Moore.

[mcculac]

I thought Auburn was looking good; a Top 20 Quarterback, a Top 5 Running Back, and now a Top 15 Receiever with an average overall rating of 91. Then I looked at Notre Dame, who has 4 guys in these Top 25s with the top three averaging out at 95. Is there any way at all they are not ranked #1 in this game?

[fishepa]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

Interesting list, not one non-BCS player on it. Not that I really like Steele that much. The two names that were left off the EA list that raised an eybrow for me, wre Bowe of LSU, whom I think is a better player than Doucet, and Urrutia from Louisville.

Urritia is a bad ***, sort of reminds of Mike Williams.

[MassNole]

Quote: Originally Posted by The Soldier

Says the guy who just complained that a guy with a career high of 614 yards isn't on there at about 10-12.

Yeah, but in his one season Greg Carr has 2 more TDs than McKnight has in his career, and is a sophomore who was on at least one All-ACC 1st Team last year compared to an underachieving senior.

I didn't even get to flash in the pan Courtney Taylor, coming off a of whopping 278 yards, and 2 less career TDs than Carr despite 2 seasons more of experience.

[coogrfan]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

Interesting list, not one non-BCS player on it. Not that I really like Steele that much. The two names that were left off the EA list that raised an eybrow for me, wre Bowe of LSU, whom I think is a better player than Doucet, and Urrutia from Louisville.

PS's list has 66 players (not sure why ) . There are a lot of non-BCS guys included, they just didn't crack his top 25.

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by fishepa

Urritia is a bad ***, sort of reminds of Mike Williams.

Agreed. Although he actually seems a little smoother than Williams did at the same points in their careers.