Lindy's Top QB's

[noplace]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

Wait, you don't think Tebow should be there, but Sam Keller should? What has Keller ever done?

No you should be answering those questions about Tebow. I know he was highly recruited in all but dude only came in on short yardage plays. What were his stats?

[noplace]

Quote: Originally Posted by The Soldier

I tried to think of an analogy for how unreliable PAC 10 preseason QB ratings are, but I couldn't think of one. USC's QB will be good. 1-2 other QBs will be very good. However, it will never be the same QB two years in a row. Kiper is an idiot, and Keller isn't that great.

Not saying he's the greatest out there but I'd take him over Tebow in a sec. We dont even know if Tebow can pass at this level yet. Dude was just a fullback playing QB & all of a sudden he's the 10th best QB in the nation?

[noplace]

Quote: Originally Posted by The Soldier

He started half a season. Well, he started in an embarrassing loss in 2004 to a 3-8 team, but I'll let that slide. And at that time in the season, USC had a good defense. I think that was the game they started accumulating injuries.

You act like ASU has Florida type talent...

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by noplace

No you should be answering those questions about Tebow. I know he was highly recruited in all but dude only came in on short yardage plays. What were his stats?

What do stats have to do with anything. Stats don't equal talent. Besides have you ever even seen Keller play? If you have, I wonder why would be so high on him. Keller is at Nebraska for a reason, because he couldn't beat out Rudy Carpenter to keep his job at ASU.

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by noplace

You act like ASU has Florida type talent...

And. That ASU offense wasn't exactly void of NFL talent at the skill position. They had guys who now play on Sundays at every position.

[MassNole]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

And. That ASU offense wasn't exactly void of NFL talent at the skill position. They had guys who now play on Sundays at every position.

Not to be a smart ***, but what ASU running back is in the NFL?

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by MassNole

Not to be a smart ***, but what ASU running back is in the NFL?

Hakim Hill probably would have been. Off-field issues led to him getting the boot, he's now in the CFL.

Rudy Burgess who's plays both WR and RB, will play on Sundays.

My point was, the argument that Keller didn't have talent around him is ridiculous. Arizona St. isn't a great team, but they never lack for playmakers on the offensive side of the ball, and Dirk Koetter is one of the most respected offensive minds in the game.

I swear, has anyone seen Keller play? I really wonder. If he was as good as his hype, he'd still be at ASU.

[Cebby]

I saw him play against Arizona in 2004 and thought he looked pretty good. Not top 5 pick in the draft good, but good enough.