Which Game Should I buy?

[phootball]

Didn't buy a football game last year, for reasons I won't go into.

Recently wanted to play again. Last NCAA I have 2006. Now there is 2007 and 2008. Which game is better? For PS2.

Thanks in advance.

[nickaepi]

I have asked the same question..I still have '06 myself. What level/sliders do you play with? Just curious...

[ehh]

'08 is the best IMO.

'06 had too many dropped passes (although this wasn't an issue on PS2 IIRC) and '07 the deep ball was way too easy to complete.

Add in slide protection, more defensive audibles, harder recruiting, etc and '08 on last-gen is the best football game ever made.

[crques]

Quote: Originally Posted by ehh

'08 is the best IMO. '06 had too many dropped passes (although this wasn't an issue on PS2 IIRC) and '07 the deep ball was way too easy to complete. Add in slide protection, more defensive audibles, harder recruiting, etc and '08 on last-gen is the best football game ever made.

I prefer 08 slightly over 06. 07 was decent, but 08 is the best way to go. my only complaint with it is the turnovers that somehow get out of hand, especially interceptions.

[aszxcv]

07 had the more stars

[ehh]

Quote: Originally Posted by crques

I prefer 08 slightly over 06. 07 was decent, but 08 is the best way to go. my only complaint with it is the turnovers that somehow get out of hand, especially interceptions.

Interesting, I haven't seen bad TO's at all. Using Penn State's defense (which is good-to-great) I have trouble forcing TO's. The only time it's bad for me is if I'm playing on the road in a tough stadium and the home team has momentum it'll turn into a fumble-fest from time to time. Besides that issue I think the turnovers are solid.