Top 25 Polls

[metallicatz]

Well i tend to think it's accurate because in real life people would be skeptical of Indiana even if they came out of nowhere and won the Big 10. It's kinda like how Boise State went undeafeted last year and only made it so far in the rankings, and then came into this year at like #22 or something. A program needs to consistently win games over the course of at least a couple of seasons to typically have access to the top of the rankings. But then that's not to say that there aren't some instances of flawed ranking logic in the game.......I just haven't had much problem with it in my Indiana dynsaty so far. I didn't have a problem becoming a top team in the rankings with my Duke dynasty in NCAA 07, I just needed to sustain the pace and win games.

[jello1717]

I play on the 360 as Michigan and North Carolina. At the start of my 2nd season, I noticed that Miami was an A+ team but only ranked about 50th in the country (I'm not sure how they did the previous year).
Miami went 5-0, including a win over defending National Champion, and current #1 in the country Oklahoma, and they STILL didn't crack the top 25.

I think that's a serious problem and not very realistic at all. Florida State was an A+ overall, went 4-0 including a win over #2 Virginia Tech and they didn't crack the top 25 either.