Favorite NCAA Football Game

[grunt]

NCAA 04 may be the best playing football game of all time but NCAA 07 gave it a run for its money. Just a complete game with all the bells and whistles.

[wonderl33t]

04 was awesome. 07 was ruined by momentum. 06 was ruined by impact players. I actually enjoyed 05 the most online because it was so freakin hard to score. My win % was around .700 and I only averaged 16.5 points per game.

The only thing I didn't like about 05 was that while every other team suffered from the dropsies, when Jason White threw the ball, their WRs would catch it every time no matter what.

[stoncold32]

I personally think 04 was best not only because it was fun, BUT mostly b/c of the talent pool in college football at that time. EVERYBODY was on that game.

[jclem92]

NCAA 03

I played like 15 years with my dad as Army and Navy

[Pierzynski 12]

NCAA 08. Because, i never played 04.

[Cebby]

I voted 2006. Probably would have been 07 or 08 if I played them on the original Xbox.

2004 was definitely the peak of the series when you take into account when the game was made. 2004 was (prior to 08 on the 360) the last time any major improvements were made.

That said, if the INT issue wasn't in 08, 08 on the 360 was by far the best game.

[nymets3000]

I pretty much rate video games on how long I play it until I stop. 2003 was sick, I played something like 9 seasons with it. This year's version is probably second with like 5 years, but I'm still playing it. 07 and 05 I really couldn't finish more than 2 seasons, I didn't like either one of them. I never bought 04 and 06.

[OSUPiper]

Quote: Originally Posted by Cardot

To me, it was 2003 that took a huge jump from previous versions. 2004 nicely built upon and improved the foundation of 2003. I think that '03 often gets overlooked in these discussions. '03 Did have many of the items on the wishlists for '09....lol. While the series has made a bit of a comeback the last two seasons, I think the progress since '04 has been disappointing. Heck, there are even some folks here that have actually gone back to '04.

I am still playing 2004, lol.