Predictions on the top 5 Highest Rated Players in NCAA 10

[jbdeuce]

I'm still waiting for someone to post the ratings that will make Tebow a 99 rated QB in this game!!!!!! McCoy has Awr, Spd, THACC, THPWR, Spin, Juke, stiff arm, Acceleration, Jump, Carries, tackle, and a little bit of trucking. lol. Someone show me what ratings in this game make Tim Tebow a 99 rated player. We all know that certain ratings make video game players great without being rated 99 overall. McCoy #1 overall!

P.S. this is a great discussion/ debate in my opinion.

[longshanks]

Quote: Originally Posted by mmorg

I can see Taylor Mays getting up in the top 5 along with Eric Berry. They are 2 of the best safeties in the history of College Football and are both projected to be top 10 picks in the next NFL Draft. You can't count out Mays because he doesn't put up the stats, but that's what I call the Nnamdi Asomugha treatment. QB's rarely throw to him. Just like Big Ben against the Ravens in the playoffs last year. You barely saw Reed in on any plays because the opposing offense kept the ball away from him. You have to respect a play that whole offenses avoid.

meh, anybody can drop deep in cover 2/cover 3 every play

and i wouldn't call it the Asomugha treatment, shaun taylor was a great safety and made plays on an even better defense than that of usc

no way he's one of the best safeties of all times.....lol

[jbdeuce]

I don't think Mays should be rated 99 eventhough he is a very good safety in my book. Its like he's talented but doesn't make many plays thats why I say no on a 99 rating. Maybe because teams are ducking him. But when you look at his attributes on paper its hard not to say he shouldn't be rated 99. That dude's size and skills are amazing!

But like I say, just because someone is overrated, that doesn't mean they are sad.

[jbdeuce]

And Mays brings me back to Tebow! lol Mays, who I don't think should be rated 99, could be because all these attributes would be rated high. Spd, ACC, Tackle, Hit Power, Man Cov., Zone Cov, AWR, Pursuit, Press, Stamina, Catch, and Block shedding...maybe even more ratings. So his 99 overall can be backed up. Show me the ratings for Tebow.

[longshanks]

Quote: Originally Posted by jbdeuce

And Mays brings me back to Tebow! lol Mays, who I don't think should be rated 99, could be because all these attributes would be rated high. Spd, ACC, Tackle, Hit Power, Man Cov., Zone Cov, AWR, Pursuit, Press, Stamina, Catch, and Block shedding...maybe even more ratings. So his 99 overall can be backed up. Show me the ratings for Tebow.

yeah, he's a specimen, he just has good measurables, i think if u put him in a situation where he would be forced to make plays i still don't think he would deliver/ be a game changer like berry

[tbuck0027]

Quote: Originally Posted by jbdeuce

I'm still waiting for someone to post the ratings that will make Tebow a 99 rated QB in this game!!!!!! McCoy has Awr, Spd, THACC, THPWR, Spin, Juke, stiff arm, Acceleration, Jump, Carries, tackle, and a little bit of trucking. lol. Someone show me what ratings in this game make Tim Tebow a 99 rated player. We all know that certain ratings make video game players great without being rated 99 overall. McCoy #1 overall! P.S. this is a great discussion/ debate in my opinion.

Tebow has all of those too...

[TrevJo]

Quote: Originally Posted by jbdeuce

I'm still waiting for someone to post the ratings that will make Tebow a 99 rated QB in this game!!!!!! McCoy has Awr, Spd, THACC, THPWR, Spin, Juke, stiff arm, Acceleration, Jump, Carries, tackle, and a little bit of trucking. lol. Someone show me what ratings in this game make Tim Tebow a 99 rated player.

I'm not sure exactly what it is that you are objecting to.

But according to a spreadsheet posted on easports.com last June ( http://easports.com/downloads/easpor...oster_info.xls ),
Tebow was already a 99 as a junior in NCAA 09. So if you think he should be a 99 for NCAA 10 then I guess you're going to be disappointed.

PLYR_LASTNAME	QB #15
PLYR_YEAR	Junior
PLYR_POSITION	QB
PLYR_OVERALLRATING	99
PLYR_SPEED	84
PLYR_STRENGTH	85
PLYR_AGILITY	82
PLYR_ACCELERATION	84
PLYR_AWARENESS	88
PLYR_BREAKTACKLE	84
PLYR_TRUCKING_NG	90
PLYR_ELUSIVENESS_NG	65
PLYR_BCVISION_NG	85
PLYR_STIFFARM_NG	88
PLYR_SPINMOVE_NG	80
PLYR_JUKEMOVE_NG	80
PLYR_CARRYING	85
PLYR_THROWPOWER	97
PLYR_THROWACCURACY	93
PLYR_STAMINA	93
PLYR_INJURY	95

[TrevJo]

Quote: Originally Posted by TrevJo

according to a spreadsheet posted on easports.com last June ( http://easports.com/downloads/easpor...oster_info.xls ), Tebow was already a 99 as a junior in NCAA 09.

Interesting by the way to see that Aaron Curry was rated 88, with 80 speed and 78 strength. Pretty moderate attributes for a guy who a year later would run a 4.56 40 and bench 25 reps at the combine, en route to a probable top 5 draft selection!