IMO, NCAA 10 Kicks Madden 10's Booty

[stevedrumsdw]

Quote: Originally Posted by Solidice

for me the pursuit angles were the worst part of '09, there were times(not every play) that there would be 3-4 defenders waiting for me in the endzone because their angles took them there for some reason. on punt returns, you basically got a 21 player escort into the endzone. that "greased pig" animation was bad as well. thankfully neither one of those are in 10.

yeah no kidding, pursuit angles were dreadful.

[jhawkmike]

I think maybe what EA was trying to accomplish in NCAA 2009 was to force users to take control and makes defensive plays themselves. They were successful in this respect and I think this is what made NCAA 2009 so much fun to play against other humans. But this is also what made the CPU even easier to dominate than usual.

[NoDakHusker]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

And I did it on the Hardcore settings.

you want a medal for that?

On topic...
I like NCAA 10 mainly because I love college football more than pros. I don't own Madden but I played it earlier at a friends house and it was ok. Commentary is bland as can be, I'd rather hear the same stuff I've heard for years in the NCAA games than this guy. Presentation isn't all that great, at least not what it's all cracked up to be.
So NCAA is my pick.

[tyler289]

If Hammond was replaced with Al Michaels, or hell, anyone else, Madden's presentation would be a lot better. The presentation overall isn't that amazing. You see the same 2-3 overlays in the beginning of every game and there are few stat overlays during gameplay. Atmosphere is better than NCAA but that's not difficult to do since there is none in NCAA.

Madden's gameplay, though, is far superior. QB styles, pro-tak, just overall feels better.

[BadAssHskr]

both games bring something to the table. ncaa feels like college, and madden feels like nfl.

all just depends on which style of play you prefer i think.

[Skyboxer]

Quote: Originally Posted by CKW11

I like Madden way more than i like NCAA. Madden is just plain more fun to me.

Same here and it's not even in the same ball park. If I wasn't in an OD with NCAA, NCAA would be gone.

[fsufan4423]

Quote: Originally Posted by 2krules

The reason I'm comparing is because I want to vent after spending money and being so disappointed.

I meant everybody in general. I often wonder what the bench mark for time spent playing a game to consider it a success.

I have what I consider some pretty good games that I barely play. I waste money on just about every game I buy. How long would you have to play a game to consider it not disappointing?

Just a general thought...not trying to bust your b@lls

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by ndhusker90

you want a medal for that? On topic... I like NCAA 10 mainly because I love college football more than pros. I don't own Madden but I played it earlier at a friends house and it was ok. Commentary is bland as can be, I'd rather hear the same stuff I've heard for years in the NCAA games than this guy. Presentation isn't all that great, at least not what it's all cracked up to be. So NCAA is my pick.

No but I would like you to mind your own business!

I was explaining to 2K that running the ball is very possible on Madden 10 even at its highest setting!