Is NCAA 10 Really Broken?

[dopeboy206]

I just finished reading Pastapadre's article on his website and read there was alot of stuff people dislike about the game from all the comments made by people. I haven't picked up a copy yet and is deciding between this game or Madden 10. I read somewhere that Pasta said the patch is broken. Is this true? For people who own both Madden and NCAA this year. What game gave you a better experience?

[Young J 334]

Quote: Originally Posted by dopeboy206

I just finished reading Pastapadre's article on his website and read there was alot of stuff people dislike about the game from all the comments made by people. I haven't picked up a copy yet and is deciding between this game or Madden 10. I read somewhere that Pasta said the patch is broken. Is this true? For people who own both Madden and NCAA this year. What game gave you a better experience?

Definitely enjoying Madden more for the first time since 05. The only reason I still have NCAA is for two reasons. 1) I'ma trophy junkie and 2) I'm in a great sim OD that's just too hard to leave

[Herky]

It's not anywhere near broken as a whole but there are areas that need a patch. It's a playable game but when you get into franchise it gets frustrating with the "progression on steroids".

[dopeboy206]

Quote: Originally Posted by VikingFan4Ever

It's not anywhere near broken as a whole but there are areas that need a patch. It's a playable game but when you get into franchise it gets frustrating with the "progression on steroids".

So players attributes and ratings in dynasty mode are still going up high year after year?

[Herky]

Quote: Originally Posted by dopeboy206

So players attributes and ratings in dynasty mode are still going up high year after year?

Higher than ever.

http://www.operationsports.com/forum...nplayable.html

[dopeboy206]

Quote: Originally Posted by VikingFan4Ever

Higher than ever. http://www.operationsports.com/forum...nplayable.html

WTF NO! That is a game killer for me. Looks like it's Madden for me.

[PackAttack]

If you like playing with a smaller prestige school like Florida Atlantic, the progression issues aren't as clear. Players don't increase their atributes a lot at a smaller school.

Just consider this, If you like NCAA Football: Buy NCAA 10
If you like NFL Football: Buy Madden 10

PackAttack says it perfect.

I have both games and I like NCAA better because I like college football better. Is Madden the better game? Yes.

NCAA is far from broken though.

There are bugs in both games which are annoying.