All time best NCAA game

[Bamafan3723]

Quote: Originally Posted by ODogg

NCAA 10 is the best by far, but it could be so much better. I know some might say NCAA 04 for nostalgia reasons but go back and play that and you will change your opinion in a hurry.

Actually I still play it because I think that is the best version. Nothing to do with nostalgia. I can't stand any of the versions on the PS3 to this date.

[SalemChief]

NCAA '09 for the PS2. Was darned near perfect.

[stlstudios189]

I am still playing 09 but, I still own 05 for xbox and I think that game is pretty darn fun.

[Matt23134]

Quote: Originally Posted by Solidice

only '06.

06 is compatible, but I wouldn't call it playable. It is so choppy that it just isn't enjoyable.

I think the guy that said 03 might be on to something. I popped in 06 recently and was disappointed to find that I could put in third stringers on my O-Line and they could still be pretty effective against a first string D-Line.

I'm starting to wonder if EA has ever made a football game where ratings have truly mattered, specifically last gen. The only next gen offering (of NCAA) I've played was 08; I can't remember how that one was.

[Herky]

2004 was outstanding on the PS2. I had so much fun with that game.

[Nike Fattz]

2006 to me. I'd love for NCAA to get back to that level of success.

[cb35]

I gotta say ncaa 10 is the best ncaa game ever - the online dynasty is the best thing since sliced bread - me and 2 friends have just finished up year 4 in our dynasty - being we are in our 30s with families and all that other BS - pretty incredible. I can overlook the gameplay faults - there are a few - gotta say hands down I'm enjoying this game immensely. I cannot imagine if I had this game while in college - the ps1 version was fun enough but online dynasty mind blowing.

Now if only the baseball developers would just steal this idea and make it work for baseball............

[FORMULA316]

Quote: Originally Posted by coogrfan

Wasn't that the one with the excessive drops and beach ball physics for tipped passes?

That's the one. I preferred 06. I have it running on the 360 but I also
preferred the smooth gameplay on the original Xbox. Sigh for giving it away.