Who should be the highest rated player by postion?

[longshanks]

Quote: Originally Posted by Palo20

QB: Keenum/Ponder HB: Ingram WR: Green TE: DJ Williams/Rudolph T: Carimi G: Hudson C: Pouncey DE: Romeus/Clayborn/Quinn DT: Austin OLB: Travis Lewis MLB: Greg Jones CB: Peterson S: Barron/DeAndre McDaniel/Rahim Moore

I agree with your list, here's my additions

QB: Kellen Moore has to be top 3, along with Locker/Ponder/Keenum
CB: Aaron Williams Tx

[cparrish]

Quote: Originally Posted by MWillard2

Julio Jones is as overrated as they come. Sure he can jump high and make freakish catches, but he is a terrible route runner and catches the ball with his body. AJ Green, Jonathan Baldwin are better than him

Agreed

[icmOU72]

Quote: Originally Posted by MWillard2

Julio Jones is as overrated as they come. Sure he can jump high and make freakish catches, but he is a terrible route runner and catches the ball with his body. AJ Green, Jonathan Baldwin are better than him

If Jones would have come to a university that doesnt just rely on pounding the ball and playing great defense, he would be an all-american. I will still never understand why he went to a school where he will probably have less than 15 career td catches when he could have come to ou and got that in a year. I dont think mark ingram is even the best rb on his team. That richardson kid looked really good. I gotta believe that ryan broyles of OU is a top 5 reciever.

[MWillard2]

Quote: Originally Posted by icmOU72

If Jones would have come to a university that doesnt just rely on pounding the ball and playing great defense, he would be an all-american. I will still never understand why he went to a school where he will probably have less than 15 career td catches when he could have come to ou and got that in a year. I dont think mark ingram is even the best rb on his team. That richardson kid looked really good. I gotta believe that ryan broyles of OU is a top 5 reciever.

AJ Green, Jonathan Baldwin, Ryan Broyles, Michael Floyd, Jeff Fuller are all better.

[UATide]

Quote: Originally Posted by icmOU72

If Jones would have come to a university that doesnt just rely on pounding the ball and playing great defense, he would be an all-american. I will still never understand why he went to a school where he will probably have less than 15 career td catches when he could have come to ou and got that in a year. I dont think mark ingram is even the best rb on his team. That richardson kid looked really good. I gotta believe that ryan broyles of OU is a top 5 reciever.

Ingram is not the best RB on our team, and still got Heisman. Richardson is a much more complete back, trust me. Just wait and see....

Back on topic:

QB: Locker
RB: Ingram
WR: Green

[Bamafan3723]

Quote: Originally Posted by icmOU72

If Jones would have come to a university that doesnt just rely on pounding the ball and playing great defense, he would be an all-american. I will still never understand why he went to a school where he will probably have less than 15 career td catches when he could have come to ou and got that in a year. I dont think mark ingram is even the best rb on his team. That richardson kid looked really good. I gotta believe that ryan broyles of OU is a top 5 reciever.

Julio needs to concentrate on catching the ball when it hits him in the hands. That has nothing to do with Alabama's offensive style. As to the bolded portion of your post, maybe he wanted to be a national champion.

[tommycoa]

As an Alabama fan, Julio Jones is one of the most overrated player to play the game in the past couple of years. I would not call him a flop. He has made some big plays. Mainly in his freshman season. He dropped at least 20 passes last season. Colin Peak was our most dependable receiver last season. Followed by Maze and Hanks. Juilio (pardon the pun) really dropped the ball last season. Sure, there were a few exceptions, Auburn and LSU. Trent Richardson will probably take the starting job by the 5th game of the season. Ingram isn't even in the same ball park as him. Richardson is one of the most complete backs I have ever seen strap on pads. I seen him make some spectacular grabs in the spring game. Its a shame Ingram and Richardson aren't on the field at the same time. Could you imagine a triple option wrinkle with these 2 guys.

[ConVick]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bruce Wayne Jr

i'll throw out a few... qb: j. locker rb: m. ingram wr. j. jones or a. green de: r. quinn lb: ? db. p. peterson

The offensive players on this list are not the best at their position....they're just popular.