Do the people at EA even watch college football?

[Eagles931]

Quote: Originally Posted by Buckeyes_Doc

LOL I can only imagine how a Penn St fan feels, when I'm an OSU fan and I'm confused at the rating lol.

I saw their rating and i just stared at my tv for a good 30 seconds. no lie lol

[xgoredhawksx]

The 95 overall OSU DT has never even been named honorable mention all conference according to my friend...

I'm not sure Saine or Herron have been all conference either and they are 94 and 92 respectively...

[dreezymac]

How EA decides ratings are as subjective as any typical fan. We should only hold them responsible for the things they actually mold like visuals, gameplay, etc.

[1GATORFAN4EVA]

Another perfect example is FSU got almost a A for defenses lol...

EA you do know they were ranked one of the worst on defense. Like 108th if I remember right, you know EA wanted to give them A's across the board lol.

[BIGD419]

Quote: Originally Posted by Buckeyes_Doc

I'm sure they watch college football but it seems like their rating system needs work and has needed work for awhile. I'm shocked to see Ohio State with an A+ offense.

I agree 100% as a Buckeye fan. Maye an A defense and A- or B+ offense would have been more expectable.

[dan_457]

Quote: Originally Posted by xgoredhawksx

The 95 overall OSU DT has never even been named honorable mention all conference according to my friend... I'm not sure Saine or Herron have been all conference either and they are 94 and 92 respectively...

Being named all conference necessarily doesn't mean anything, Devier Posey is an awesome WR and wasn't named all confrence. Besides I wouldn't really question tOSU defensive rating, but i do understand that Saine and herron along with the offense OVR are overrated.

[DonkeyJote]

Masoli was kicked off the team on June 9th. The game was finalized on June 1st. So short of firing up ye olde DeLorean, there's no way for them to have known he wouldn't be on the team.

[Chrisleakfan4life]

What i don't get is, how did Florida's QB John Brantley drop from an 89 overall in 2010, to an 86 in 2011 when he had a much better year statistically as a backup last year.