Is it safe to say this game is the best NCAA Football game of all time?

[dopeboy206]

First off I just want to say I've been playing college football games since NCAA Gamebreaker 98 and NCAA football since 99. I played Madden since 95 so I am not new to football games.

Just one day into the game I already know and could safely say this is the best NCAA Football game so far. Out the box this game is GOOD TO GO! Other NCAA games this gen needs to be patched to improve gameplay and even when they were patched they still have nothing on NCAA Football 11 out the box. Trust me I owned them all.

NCAA 11 = G.O.A.T. when it comes to college football games. Yes even better than NCAA Football 06. I said it!

PS: The way I feel about this game might be premature but I could feel that this game is going to be great. NCAA is headed in the right direction.

[Garam05]

I'm hesitant to vote on this yet. I always thought 04 and 06 were on nearly equal footing, with 04 maybe a little ahead. I think that 11 is around the same level as 06, but I don't know if I'd give it the edge over 04 yet. If I had to rate them, I'd give 04 a 9.5 and 06/11 both a 9.3ish. Once I delve into dynasty mode, this may change drastically.

[dopeboy206]

Quote: Originally Posted by Garam05

I'm hesitant to vote on this yet. I always thought 04 and 06 were on nearly equal footing, with 04 maybe a little ahead. I think that 11 is around the same level as 06, but I don't know if I'd give it the edge over 04 yet. If I had to rate them, I'd give 04 a 9.5 and 06/11 both a 9.3ish. Once I delve into dynasty mode, this may change drastically.

04 is also a great title wasn't that the one with Carson on the cover? If I had to rate them it would be like this.

Best
1. '11
2. '06
3. '04

Worst
1. '08
2. '05
3. '07 (xbox 360/ps3 version not last gen version)

[Garam05]

Yep, 04 had Carson Palmer on it. I need more time with the new one, and I don't have to work for 12 more hours soooo... time to go get a couple games in.

[raiders81tim]

I think its just alot of new car smell right now. The game still has alot of issues, not seen in last gen games.

[elvistatexas]

its ok the running is suspect especially runnin between tha tackles

[dopeboy206]

Quote: Originally Posted by elvistatexas

its ok the running is suspect especially runnin between tha tackles

Don't know about u bruh but I am loving the running game.

[Jerseys Very Own]

Its definitely in the top 3 I believe but I think 2006 was the best one. But trust me I think it can only get better if E.A. builds on top not knockdown and start all over.