Found A "HUGE" Issue with Dynasty Recruiting

And it involved the Quarterback position. I have simmed 4 years into dynasty to see how players are progressing (I edit my own rosters). I just went through every team to see how things are looking with the progression of the Re-Rated Quarterbacks and they are VERY VERY good. But the issue is teams recruitment of Quarterbacks. They are overflowing with them and these teams are only loading up on 5-7 OL per year.

1 QB-
2 QB-
3 QB- 20
4 QB- 27
5 QB- 34
6 QB- 18
7 QB- 10
8 QB- 6
9 QB- 4
10 QB- 1

The lower rated teams were not the only teams with lots of QB because of Walk-Ons. I saw numerous 4 Star teams having lots of Quarterbacks. Since we have tuning options I think this could be a easy thing to fix.

[Roggie]

TEN quarterbacks on a team? You're kidding, right?

[dan_457]

Quote: Originally Posted by MattUMD224

And it involved the Quarterback position. I have simmed 4 years into dynasty to see how players are progressing (I edit my own rosters). I just went through every team to see how things are looking with the progression of the Re-Rated Quarterbacks and they are VERY VERY good. But the issue is teams recruitment of Quarterbacks. They are overflowing with them and these teams are only loading up on 5-7 OL per year. 1 QB- 2 QB- 3 QB- 20 4 QB- 27 5 QB- 34 6 QB- 18 7 QB- 10 8 QB- 6 9 QB- 4 10 QB- 1 The lower rated teams were not the only teams with lots of QB because of Walk-Ons. I saw numerous 4 Star teams having lots of Quarterbacks. Since we have tuning options I think this could be a easy thing to fix.

Probably could be patched, but honestly, what are the odds they'll even touch this, i say 0%.

[dvdad]

In last year's game I played a team in my dynasty that had literally 25 CB's with what appeared to be walk-ons at TE,OL,DL and LB. I doubt that it'll be fixed in a patch.

I'm doing another simulation now to see results.

[Whoman]

this in general is part of the reason why the lower prestige teams really suck later on, i would expect a 3* QB to go a couple teams down on his list rather than signing with a team where he´s 7th on the depth chart.

In real life i think that Positions like QB and HB are actually filled with good players even at smaller programs, the problem starts in "depth-positions" like the Oline where they may have 1 or 2 serviceable guys but also 2 or 3 guys that are just totally outmatched on most nights.

a 1 or 2 star CPU controlled program in the game will basically never sign a 3 star player, i´d like for them to be able to "pick up the scraps" at the skills positions at least .

[rjsuperfly66]

Sadly this is an important thing which hurts teams later on.

Your roster size is 70.

If you are developing 10 QBS, that means you are taking away 6-7 spots from developing other players.

Development is important (ie redshirt), so you don't just get a 60 rated freshman and have to throw him in your lineup.

[youALREADYknow]

Please make sure this gets noticed by the NCAA devs. Things like this will kill replay value for all serious dynasty mode players.