Awareness for CPU QB's and how it effects their decision making

[carnalnirvana]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IahzNyx0908

a quick quarter i recorded, the user play is bugged since my friends were pushing to play MK9 i rushed it but focus on the cpu play and their in experienced QB... i dont think he played clueless but his accuracy was an issue

[Palo20]

Quote: Originally Posted by carnalnirvana

its part of the solution....the cpu likes to come out in 3wr sets and runs from it wayyyy too often. on 3rd down i can understand everyone bringing in a third WR but on first and second most teams use 2wr 2TE and a FB etc.....obviously there are teams that likes multiple wr/te... pats,colts, GB etc ........college is obviously different.... i am currently going through last season nfl games to see how often teams came out in 3+ wr sets, and what % did they use it.... from my experience in madden teams rarely pass from 2 wr sets

Search for a thread in the madden forums from last september or so where we were making gameplans for every team. There is a chart in there with tendencies and 3 WR % for every team from 2009.

I can't access the chart at the moment.

[carnalnirvana]

Quote: Originally Posted by Palo20

Search for a thread in the madden forums from last september or so where we were making gameplans for every team. There is a chart in there with tendencies and 3 WR % for every team from 2009. I can't access the chart at the moment.

for the gameplans, yep i found it..... thx

[atlplayboy23]

Great read. I might just have to pick this game up for 360 since playmaker and you guys are working on regular rosters. I had a idea about qb accuracy take the completion percent and add 20 to it to get the rating.

EX
Dan Persa 73.5 would be 94 accuracy
Kellen Moore 71.3 = 91 accuracy
Andrew Luck 70.7 = 91 accuracy
2008 Colt McCoy 76.7 = 97 accuracy
1998 Dante Cullpepper who held it before McCoy 73.6 = 94 accuracy
1994 Chris Hatcher divsion 1aa 74.9 = 95 accuracy

[Gotmadskillzson]

Accuracy in the 90s they are going to miss, maybe 4 or 5 throws a game. Heck in the high 80s they rarely miss. I tend to not like QB accuracy rating above 85.

[atlplayboy23]

Well just at 10 to it. The lowest rated dude would be Diondre Borel 53.2 = 63. There would only be 3 dudes in the 90s this year based on last year stats. Persa Moore and Luck and the highest ever was McCoy with 76.7 I think the completion % in the 70s deserve 90 because its rare to have a 70 percent completion rating

[Palo20]

Quote: Originally Posted by atlplayboy23

Great read. I might just have to pick this game up for 360 since playmaker and you guys are working on regular rosters. I had a idea about qb accuracy take the completion percent and add 20 to it to get the rating. EX Dan Persa 73.5 would be 94 accuracy Kellen Moore 71.3 = 91 accuracy Andrew Luck 70.7 = 91 accuracy 2008 Colt McCoy 76.7 = 97 accuracy 1998 Dante Cullpepper who held it before McCoy 73.6 = 94 accuracy 1994 Chris Hatcher divsion 1aa 74.9 = 95 accuracy

I don't like this. Accuracy is so much more than comp %. It's as much decision making as it is accuracy.

Persa and Northwestern run a ton of WR screens, that skews his comp %.

Teams that throw downfield more will have a lower comp %, but even if they're at 58% and making big plays, that takes a ton of accuracy.

Comp% can be very misleading.

[atlplayboy23]

So what do you suggest right now its a ton of qbs in the 90s and I dont think it should be that way. Trying to find a good measure for this. You have two separate ratings for awr and acc so it has to take in account the awr rating and come up with a good way to measure accuracy. Also have to take into account the teams receivers too.