Anyone win the Heisman Trophy?

[Shibito]

You guys act like stats alone determine Heisman, wrong. Team success is a huge factor as well. You will have a hard time winning the Heismen award without at least making a BCS bowl.

My first dynasty and my QB Crist at ND finished with a tad over 5,000 yards and 48 TD passes and lost to Andrew Luck. Why? I dropped 2 games and Stanford went undefeated.

Quote: Originally Posted by Andrews85

Has anyone ever won or even got on the list with a defensive player (Non-RTG)? My 1st Season as PITT DC I tried to win the Heisman with Max Gruder (MLB). I failed miserably, never even got on the list. I didn't even win the Butkus Award, I finished 3rd even tho I had much better stats then the winner.

Yes, but I had to cheat to do it.

[TreyDobbs]

1,879 yards, 31 TDs; 536 receiving yards, 4 TDs; 2400 all purpose yards, 35 TDs and I'm only through 8 games with SDSU and Ronnie Hillman. I should win it, but just because I've put up these stats doesn't mean I'm blowing teams out. I'm OC for SDSU and I'm having close games. I'm 7-1 with my lone loss to Michigan at the Big House on the last drive. I can't pass worth **** since my QB only has 1200 yards, 9 TDs, 14 INTs so I rely on the run constantly.

[gramazio987]

Quote: Originally Posted by Marcus34

Nope, I led the nation in rushing last season and never even made it on to the watch list smh

I led the NCAA with Montell Harris on BC and didn't even break into the top 5 the entire year. Yet in year two, Rettig has 225 yards and 6td 1 int in two games and is 3rd. Explain that