Is this really out of bounds?

[Sammidysam]

So I was playing my all-american coach mode dynasty, and my quarterback threw to my receiver who looked to be perfectly in bounds, except one of his feet was out of bounds. I thought that didn't mattered so when the other coach challenged it I laughed and thought, "What a bad challenge." Then the ref came on and said it was overturned and I yelled at my TV. Here's the video, but my question is: was it actually out of bounds or just a glitch?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=52ZWi...el_video_title

[WhoCares?]

Out of bounds.

NFL is both feet in
College is only 1 foot, but the inbound foot has to touch the ground first.

[Sammidysam]

Quote: Originally Posted by WhoCares?

Out of bounds. NFL is both feet in College is only 1 foot, but the inbound foot has to touch the ground first.

Oh okay...

[dochalladay32]

Quote: Originally Posted by Sammidysam

So I was playing my all-american coach mode dynasty, and my quarterback threw to my receiver who looked to be perfectly in bounds, except one of his feet was out of bounds. I thought that didn't mattered so when the other coach challenged it I laughed and thought, "What a bad challenge." Then the ref came on and said it was overturned and I yelled at my TV. Here's the video, but my question is: was it actually out of bounds or just a glitch? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=52ZWi...el_video_title

He's not perfectly in bounds if he had a foot out of bounds, now was he? Once you are out, you are out, no if's, and's, or but's in this situation.

[Sammidysam]

Quote: Originally Posted by dochalladay32

He's not perfectly in bounds if he had a foot out of bounds, now was he? Once you are out, you are out, no if's, and's, or but's in this situation.

Yeah I didn't know the rules very well, but it's cleared up now.

[RGmoney]

Closing this up. OP, now knows the rules.