Same plays keep popping up in Custom Playbook during Game

[skillzlikewhoa12]

I created a custom playbook post patch based on Boise State. I wanted a little of everything in there. I have something like 28 formations. Shotgun, Ace, Wishbone, Flexbone, Pistol, ect.

Anyways, I am in my offline dynasty and I haven't had any freezing issues or anything. The big problem I am having is the same 5 to 10 plays keep coming up.

I have it set on ask coach and from there I usually just pick one of the three plays showing. Unfortunately, despite having 375 plays I only see the option to pick from the same 5 to 10 every time. Many of my plays never even show up. I can find them if I go through the whole, pick formation and play scenario but I would rather have my coach just pick a more diverse game plan. The ask coach option always suggest goaline fade and all verts all the time.

Is this a custom playbook glitch or is the Ask Coach option just broken??

[hee163]

Ask coach is broken in my opinion. Seems to avoid certain types of play, particularly options.

[skillzlikewhoa12]

Does Ask Coach even consider the order of plays? Maybe I should re-order some plays.. Also, which formations in Custom Playbook have bugs and what does the bug do?

[Herky]

I don't use custom playbooks but I do use Ask A Coach. The same plays show up for me over and over too. Same thing on defense.

[bklyn85]

Before this year I always used the ask coach, but with custom playbooks in the game I started calling my own plays simply for the reason you have. Variety. I call a different play on any given drive and will only call the same play from the same formation maybe 2 or at the most 3 times a game and have removed all of the 4 verts out of my playbook. Keeps the game intriguing and I can call plays based on the situation and flow of the game. Best bet is just to call your own plays and don't be repetitive.