NCAA '11 or '12???

[The GOAT 1988]

So i had both of these games in the past but each frustrated me so i traded them in. but im missin that joy from recruiting and controlling a team to greatness and i needed some input on which to get:

'12 was so buggy i wanted to shoot myself. have they fixed the coaching carousel or absurd player progression? i might just turn that off if it fixes player progression but i dont like the idea of coach ratings staying stagnant forever. also i remember the gameplay having problems, but if someone could fill me in.

'11 is older but i remember liking the gameplay more and found games enjoyable. however you dont have custom conferences but coach ratings did change.

also, do both of the games have tuners that fixed the recruiting logic of the CPU to not over-recruit at certain positions?

thanks for any and all help

[belucheez2]

NCAA 11 didn't have Coaching Carousel....

[The GOAT 1988]

woops sorry i mean '12 and '11 respectively i will fix that in the original post

[belucheez2]

Alright that is what I thought originally but I just got really confused. I didn't play NCAA 12 but I still play NCAA 11 almost daily so I will give the pros and cons of it.

Pros
1. The game-play was probably the best of any NCAA game since Xbox 360 came out. It brought a lot to the table in my opinion and is still a fun game to play even though it is outdated.
2. Glitches are not that bad in this game. I've played it almost everyday since it came out and it hasn't ever really had a game-breaking glitch for me. Plus the patches fixed it when NCAA 11 ran it's course.

Cons
1. Suction blocking which is reportedly fixed in NCAA 12. I hated it.
2. Schedules and Rosters outdated. The schedules(For RTG and Dynasty) and rosters are outdated because it is obviously from last year.
3. RTG doesn't have as much immersion as NCAA 12's does.

[Juce734]

2012

Teams still over recruit at some positions.

The coaching pitches change I believe.

[The GOAT 1988]

thanks guys for the input