Your thoughts on scholarship limit

[CuseGirl]

Quote: Originally Posted by schumj

Well based on their current commitment list Alabama has 27 commits this year, and they are not done recruiting. I've heard plenty on the "25 rule" via Paul Finebaum, etc., but I don't understand how hard 25 means you can have 27 verbal commits? Back to the topic if they would just change roster size to at least 85 it would help with the problem. You would still have to cut if you had 25 recruits every year but your teams could actually develop depth and then make less recruits sign with teams that have more depth at their position.

Maybe there's a data issue that they avoid by setting the roster size to 70?

to the bolded part, they probably have the Big 10's rule, where you get 3 over the 25 and I think those 3 could count onto next year or something like that? The thing is, it's still not 85 over 4 years, which the Big 10 does have.

[blkrptnt819]

Quote: Originally Posted by invisiblespoon

"Program Integrity" Schools like Michigan that have high integrity have everything you mentioned except it's the winningest program in NCAA history...

U just keep pushing Michigan huh? LOL

[blkrptnt819]

Quote: Originally Posted by schumj

Well based on their current commitment list Alabama has 27 commits this year, and they are not done recruiting. I've heard plenty on the "25 rule" via Paul Finebaum, etc., but I don't understand how hard 25 means you can have 27 verbal commits? Back to the topic if they would just change roster size to at least 85 it would help with the problem. You would still have to cut if you had 25 recruits every year but your teams could actually develop depth and then make less recruits sign with teams that have more depth at their position.

I think 75 is enough. If the recruits became aware of signings at there position then I can see 80. It's just insane that 5 5* qbs sign with one school. That makes no sense. That fact would also make signing and developing 3* athletes more important. Get rid of the mascot game and honestly i would be a huge fan of making RTG FREE DLC. That way there is more disk space for other stuff that needs to be addressed mainly gameplay.

[CuseGirl]

Quote: Originally Posted by blkrptnt819

U just keep pushing Michigan huh? LOL

half a national title since what, World War 2? lol

Quote: Originally Posted by blkrptnt819

Get rid of the mascot game and honestly i would be a huge fan of making RTG FREE DLC. That way there is more disk space for other stuff that needs to be addressed mainly gameplay.

I play RTG but I can only stand it for one QB and one RB run. That's it. And I dont even have Madden 12, so the value is fleeting. Would not blink if I had to download it.....but no way they'd give it away for free....

[stcloudgopher]

Quote: Originally Posted by CuseGirl

half a national title since what, World War 2? lol I play RTG but I can only stand it for one QB and one RB run. That's it. And I dont even have Madden 12, so the value is fleeting. Would not blink if I had to download it.....but no way they'd give it away for free....

Deal. Charge $1 for it. When only 5 percent of the gamers purchase it, maybe we can finally eliminate the mode. (Same goes for Mascot Challenge.)

[blkrptnt819]

Quote: Originally Posted by CuseGirl

I play RTG but I can only stand it for one QB and one RB run. That's it. And I dont even have Madden 12, so the value is fleeting. Would not blink if I had to download it.....but no way they'd give it away for free....

I mean with the purchase of the game, not free.

[invisiblespoon]

Quote: Originally Posted by CuseGirl

half a national title since what, World War 2? lol

If there was a tournament we'd have 20.

BTW how's Syracuse football going for you... I'm thinking of using them in an upcoming 2-Star dynasty

[krildog]

It would be nice if EA could manage to expand roster size to at least 75 or 80, if not 85. I hate having to cut 6-8 guys every offseason, and I feel it makes you sacrifice depth at positions like OL and DL in order to make it under the limit. I don't suppose splitting the game into 2 discs (like Battlefield 3), would help solve the problem? You could put Dynasty, OD and RTG on one disc, and Play Now and online modes on another.