I've heard mixed reports..but what is the best NCAA Football game (PS2 or PS3)

[bigsmallwood]

NCAA 06 is the best in the series hands down in my opinion. It had balanced gameplay and overall it was highly polished. I miss being able to create teams without team builder as well. NCAA 11 is best of next-gen NCAA.

[DickDalewood]

My vote goes to NCAA 06.

[thelasthurtknee]

07 and 08 on last gen were the best on last gen by far. 07 did have some of the pursuit angle issues and they were fixed in 08. far more complete than 06 but alot of guys didnt play them because they already made the move to next gen so they could get real time weather(remember that crap?) you had medical reshirts, spring training, qb avoidance, and could throw all the routes unlike on 06 which was actually very hard to balance the ai on pass defense between the short and deep ball. they also introduced the auto motion and had a ton a awesome plays that never made it to this gen. there were also stats for highschool players you were recruiting that were dynamic as season went on. very cool. 04 is really not that good when you go back. the players are huge compared to field, and its either the curl or out route that you couldnt throw. I also remember playing on heisman and having every slider turned down to zero for me and up to 100 for cpu and they couldnt win a game because of their play calling. you dont wanna play 04. there are good memorys only because it was the first online. not really a good game in retrospect

[vanderbiltfan87]

Quote: Originally Posted by thelasthurtknee

07 and 08 on last gen were the best on last gen by far. 07 did have some of the pursuit angle issues and they were fixed in 08. far more complete than 06 but alot of guys didnt play them because they already made the move to next gen so they could get real time weather(remember that crap?) you had medical reshirts, spring training, qb avoidance, and could throw all the routes unlike on 06 which was actually very hard to balance the ai on pass defense between the short and deep ball. they also introduced the auto motion and had a ton a awesome plays that never made it to this gen. there were also stats for highschool players you were recruiting that were dynamic as season went on. very cool. 04 is really not that good when you go back. the players are huge compared to field, and its either the curl or out route that you couldnt throw. I also remember playing on heisman and having every slider turned down to zero for me and up to 100 for cpu and they couldnt win a game because of their play calling. you dont wanna play 04. there are good memorys only because it was the first online. not really a good game in retrospect

How does 08 compare to 2009, 2010, 2011?