I found where I posted before about the inverted veer so I could quote w/o having to write it over again and see that it was you that I replied to before.
|
Quote: |
|
|
|
|
Originally Posted by jello1717 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
I absolutely LOVE the inverted veer and midline read options. The veer can be mastered, but the most important thing is the read the defense presnap. There are certain alignments where the read guy can stay at home on the QB (forcing a give to the HB) and still be able to turn and tackle the HB. With practice you can recognize when this will happen presnap and audible out of the play accordingly. I've never seen a situation where the read guy crashed on the HB and then tackled the QB after I kept it. It's only the give where he can sometimes take both players out of the play.
After you've learned to read this presnap, then the inverted veer is just as successful as read options plays. It can even be better depending on your personnel. If you've got a speed back and a power running QB, then the inverted veer is better than a read option as it has the QB pounding the middle while the HB is getting outside.
|
|
|
|
|
|
I see that I missed another post where someone asked me for specifics on the veer:
I wouldn't expect the inverted veer to be much different depending on formations, but here are the formations in my CPB from which I run the inverted veer (all shotgun formations obviously):
(11)normal
(11)wing trips wk
(12)twin te slot wk
(20)f twins over (jet inverted veer w/ a WR instead of HB)
(20)split slot
As for the presnap read, if the read guy is lineup up fully outside your tackle, then he can crash on the QB and still tackle the HB when you give him the ball. Sadly, this doesn't matter whether you're reading the strong side or weak side as the TE won't make a difference (since the of course the read guy is left unblocked). It's all about his placement relative to the tackle. If he's fully outside like this:
Then the angle at which he gets to the mesh allows him to take out the QB and then tackle the HB after you give. (FWIW, this is SG-normal v. nickle normal)
However, if he's only halfway outside the tackle like this:
then the read guy will only take out 1 guy. If he crashes on the QB, he'll finish tackling the QB after the give and the HB is free to run (although a backer will frequently squirt through the hole left by the pulling guard and run the HB down from behind unless you get to the corner quickly. (FWIW this is SG normal v. nickle 3-3-5)
This isn't just a 3 man front v. 4 man front thing either. I played around in practice a little while writing this and I ran my 12 set against the 4-3 Under w/ the LOLB on the line and in this formation the DL is shifted slightly right which makes the LE read guy slightly inside the RT like this:
and the DE can't take out both the QB and the HB. (FWIW this is SF twin TE slot Wk v. 4-3 Under)
However, running the veer against this same exact defense, but with the D flipped (or the O flipped) so that the OLB on the line is on the weak side, then the read DE is fully outside the tackle and he'll take out both QB and HB.
This has been my experience regardless of what formations from which I run the inverted veer. It's a pretty simple presnap read to let you know if you will be able to run the play at its full effectiveness or if you only have 1 possible read w/ the other read being a TFL anytime you need to give to the HB.
Now, as for PDuncanOhio's other point about the QB keep, I haven't experienced that much. I will get the occasional tackles for no gain when the QB keeps it, but this is usually only when I'm facing a big blitz up the middle. W/ my sliders I get just as many no gains or even TFLs when my QB keeps on read options. Most times my QB has just as much room to run up the gut as he would on a midline read option (where I'm reading a DT instead of a DE/OLB).
I ran some inverted veers and specifically watched to see what happens w/ the backside LB (I've never noticed before since I haven't had a problem w/ him). In the few plays I tried, the playside T (the one letting the DE go) usually blocks him or the backside T blocks him. If I'm tackled for a short gain it's actually usually the playside OLB that gets me, but the pulling backside G usually gets to him too.
As for the general effectiveness of the basic types of mesh options (read option, midline read option, inverted veer) here's how I'd rank them from my (TONS of) experience. These are obviously skewed by my sliders.
Give to HB:
1. Read option
2. Midline read option
3. Inverted Veer (It's tough to get around the corner, but w/a speed back, I've gotten some of my biggest gains by a HB on the inverted veer if he can get the corner. It has the lowest chance of success, but the biggest chance for a HUGE gain)
QB keeps:
1. Read option w/ a lead TE blocking
2. Midline read option
3. Inverted Veer
4. Read option w/o a lead blocker