Anyone want to be apart of my playoff committee?

[jp18]

What was the teams record for team E's second loss? Going 5-0 in the top 25 is exceptional and as jellio stated is of more importance to him which I agree with to a degree, but at the same time a loss to a 7-5 team is a free one but the second loss imo trumps that 5-0 top 25 record unless the 2nd team was in the 9+ win range.

[ChirpyMango01]

I would go 1A, 2C, 3F, 4E, 5D, 6G, 7B, 8H

[ZN30]

A
C
F
E

G
D
B
H

[Pandabear218]

Quote: Originally Posted by jello1717

1) Team A: (undefeated power 5 conference champ. DUH!) 2) Team C: (power 5 champ, 11-1, 4 top 25 opponents) 3) Team E: (power 5 champ, 11-2, undefeated against top 25) 4) Team F: (11-1 w/ only loss to #1 team) 5) Team G: (10-2 power 5 team with a good win over #2 team) 6A) Team D: (get in a real conference or at least schedule some top 25 teams. Couldn't decide between Teams B and D) 6B) Team B: (Nothing terribly impressive. Couldn't decide between Teams B and D) 8) Team H: (I can't believe a 9-4 team is even in consideration)

This is the way to go!


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[saffo937]

I would go with....
1. A
2. C
3. E
4. F

5. D
6. G
7. H
8. B

[nk619ny]

A
C
E
F

D
B
G
H

Though I am a big fan of quantitative info, and am not a huge fan of this information approach. At a minimum, I would want to see the combined opponent win-loss for each team (available in the "schedules" menu), and the average ranking of each conference (available by clicking on conference prestige in the "my school" section of recruiting). I feel like this adds a lot more color to strength of schedule than just Top-25 record.

[UravenzownU]

A,C,E,F

Inn that order

[jp18]

Love this thread but we need some more info or at least I do between E and D. Without knowing whom that second loss was to that wasn't in the top 25 it makes it impossible to judge all the variables. Losing a game to a 7-5 team isn't the worst but if the second loss is to a team that only has 8 wins or less they can't be a so called "elite" team. Team d on the other hand is a mystery to me without a conference and what teams they played but sure looks like they handled there business without the horrible upset. Ultimately without seeing the schedule and results of both E and D the book is based off of the vague cover.