I found the spread to be a good fit because of
a) the titans receivers are VERY weak, but can succeed against nickle/dime corners so spread em out and move em around and VY will accidentally find somebody open otherwise:
b) the spread really caters to VYs running ability as there the defense will rarely be in their base set and forced into a wide open field he can scramble successfully very often around and over corners. i wouldnt say he ran a ton but i was pleased in that most of the situations where i started thinking RUN RUN RUN he would pull it down and take it 7 yards. He will never slide though. I just assumed there wasnt a slide animation but Ive seen it a whole bunch with the other teams ive played, VY just dont play that : )
the option aspect i had some success but it honestly opened up vince to way too many big hits and he fumbled every other time, but there were some trick plays I ran with success (wr sweeps were fun). linebackers and hard hitting safeties will destroy VY in the open field if they hit him : (
the only trouble with the playbook is that the running is very weak your fullback will be nonexistent and the way dline penetration works singleback 4 wide sets wont net you too many yards. but lendale white is a bum anyway so i wasnt surprised he stunk.
i also had a very different experience than im sure you will since i was able to trade up in the 08 draft to 1.12 or so and grab mcfadden whos stock was falling. he had most of his success subbing in for the WR sweeps but overall didnt do much (other than teach me to NEVER EVER EVER give a high profile rb touchdown/yards incentives). he had a good year but certainly not great
also, albert haynesworth is a keeper. he is a beast in the interior line.
fwiw ive been using the garret pass attack for my cowboys team and im kind of ambivalent towards it. the most successful running plays for me have been iso's, and the deep passing isnt nearly as prevalent as i was expecting. Theres also more west-coast style 4 wr's all running ins and outs plays that he likes to call than I would ever want to see. Not my style.