I'm having the same issue also. I mention this in my thread. The AI needs to be fixed to allow it to read personnel. My cpu opponent also can't read my personnel. I called 4WR on 1st down and they come out in 4-3 Base defense. Also my cpu opponent has (I-formation) on the screen and when they come out they are in 4WR. This drives me crazy. Even my DC can't call the right personnel.
I think the problem arises from our call tendencies. If we call alot of running plays on first down, the cpu will see that an automatically call base defense. This is a problem. They should have the right personnel out there to match up with my personnel even if i call run.
Note: What I try to do is read all (3) playcall tendenices of my opponent and figure out which formation he might come out with. ie: if all (3) are pass plays i go into nickel. But if they are mixed run and pass, I go with the one that has the higher % being called. It sucks, but sometimes you get the right personnel. That's my only work around unless someone has a better one.
Josh, Dan, and crew can we get this fixed?