Well, then maybe I'll give this a try then. I really haven't played 2k5 since I bought Madden 06 (which I actually enjoyed), then NCAA 07 (hated it, but got my money's worth playing my roommate).
I am still on Xbox, and I highly doubt Madden and NCAA will be worth the $40 for me to get my football fix this year.
I do have a question for you puja about your rosters (I've read a fair amount of your huge thread late last night, so sorry if it is a bad qustion). Do you have updated pictures, like of all the players who weren't in the league when 2k5 was released? Could anyone tell by your rosters that they weren't done by a video gaming company, but by some individual (i.e. are they that good?).