1. NBA 2K11
2. College Hoops 2K8
3. MLB The Show 13
I've played these games the most. More than the other games I have in my library. I picked 2K11 over 12 because I only have 12 for PC because of the incredible mods.
I sill play College Hoops and it is still a great game. Wish 2K would put out a college game for PC and let the modders have at it.
I haven't owned a baseball game since NCAA 06. I have MVP 05 on the PC and was content with that until I played The Show 12. I picked up The Show 13 and have played more games than any other baseball game with the exception of MVP 05. Great game.
For all the mentions of FIFA 13...FIFA World Cup 2010 was/still is better than FIFA 13. The smoothest gameplay to date, awesome be a pro mode, and all the crazy unlockable celebrations they added. Can only hope that there is a WC 2014 and that its just as memorable. I personally feel that, gameplay wise, this was the best FIFA to date. Way too much lag in the recent versions, even when I am playing offline!