11-28-2017, 02:29 PM
|
#2
|
Rookie
|
It's not the micro transaction itself that is bad it's the lack of transparency behind them. Ultimate Team and this goes for all of them and 2K should have to abide by the same transparency and provide the same consumer protections as the Sports Trading Card Industry. Gaming companies are essentially sports trading card companies in these types of games. Gaming companies use the same marketing and advertising tactics but the Sports Trading Card Industry MUST LIST THE ODDs of all inserts, chaser cards and any player likeness that is advertised as inside a particular pack of cards.
The gambling issue is a lose lose. The courts have already spoken on this with the Sports Trading Card Industry, who went through numerous gambling lawsuits back in the 90's and early 2000s. Courts rules there was NO HARM to the buyer because he or she always received something of value back. This is the foundation on* what the loot box, crate, UT card is built on. For you kids, money isn't the only legal definition of value so forget that argument.**
Was was interesting in a particular case. Dumas v Fleer/Skyline was that Justice Brewster did agree with the plaintiffs that the marketing techniques were illegal specifically to New* York and California law. In 1992 New York issued citations to Fleer, Upper Deck, Marvel and others, hauled them all into court and that my firends is why you see odds on a pack of Baseball Cards.
This is the only argument that has merit and can be won on.* What Gaming Companies do is not gambling it's deceptive/predatory advertising.* The gambling aspect because of their use of slot machine and casino tactics would only effect MINORS access to these types of games.
My other concern is we are starting to see gaming companies apply for and receive patents that give them the technology to manipulate the in game characters, their traits, powers, etc. That could open an entirely new legal battle in the aspect of fraud in as they advertise a particular character to* have the ability to do X,Y,Z. You pay for a chance at that character, win him and they manipulate it based on not just your game skill but your opponents...* **
|
|
|