baseball sims

[Xogo]

Id like to get some opinions from people. Of the following baseball sims, which do yo think produces the most realistic and accurate results for team Wins/Losses and players stats?

OOTP 18
Action! PC Baseball
Diamond Mind
Strat-O-Matic
PC Replay Baseball
Inside Pitch Baseball

[vrobx1]

Re: baseball sims

I don't know about a lot of these games.

I play OOTP myself.

I may have to give some of these others a look.

I never played SOM on the computer but back in the day, I would play with the dice, cards and charts and I enjoyed that alot.

[BossPatriots]

Re: baseball sims

I believe that OOTP is the most realistic sim out there from personal experience. A few of those I haven't tried so I don't know if they live up to the standard of OOTP, which is quite high.

[tinpanalley]

Re: baseball sims

Does OOTP have communities that update current and historic roster sets? Because I've never really gotten into these but that sounds fun. I've been playing baseball video games since the mid-80s, it's been a long time since any game did anything truly interesting for a stats/simulation lover.

[mlb61]

Re: baseball sims

Id like to get some opinions from people. Of the following baseball sims, which do yo think produces the most realistic and accurate results for team Wins/Losses and players stats?

OOTP 18
Action! PC Baseball
Diamond Mind
Strat-O-Matic
PC Replay Baseball
Inside Pitch Baseball

OOTP comes no way near the accuracy of Strat, nor Diamond Mind for that matter, if you're talking season replay stats. Hard to top Strat-O-Matic in that regard.

[FCMAdmin]

Re: baseball sims

Id like to get some opinions from people. Of the following baseball sims, which do yo think produces the most realistic and accurate results for team Wins/Losses and players stats?

OOTP 18
Action! PC Baseball
Diamond Mind
Strat-O-Matic
PC Replay Baseball
Inside Pitch Baseball

I run a league using baseball mogul - we get fairly accurate stats, but baseball stats also change over time.

[chetan1929]

Re: baseball sims

OOTP comes no way near the accuracy of Strat, nor Diamond Mind for that matter, if you're talking season replay stats. Hard to top Strat-O-Matic in that regard.

Thats cool

[notsobabybombers]

Re: baseball sims

I believe that OOTP is the most realistic sim out there from personal experience. A few of those I haven't tried so I don't know if they live up to the standard of OOTP, which is quite high.

OOTP is a phenomenal sim. I love it.

[tinpanalley]

Re: baseball sims

Is there one that is JUST daily roster management and playing the games without ANY organisational management whatsoever? Thats the only way I'd play one. Complete mathematical simulation, no transactions, no injuries, just manging the on field stuff with nothing else going on behind the scenes.

[spike83]

Re: baseball sims

Is there one that is JUST daily roster management and playing the games without ANY organisational management whatsoever? Thats the only way I'd play one. Complete mathematical simulation, no transactions, no injuries, just manging the on field stuff with nothing else going on behind the scenes.

Sent from my BLU LIFE ONE X using Tapatalk

Try Diamond Mind Baseball.

[dodgerblue]

Re: baseball sims

I think OOTP is good for historical stats over several seasons and plays the ‘what if’ scenario really well. As far as season replays I favor Strat.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[tinpanalley]

Re: baseball sims

I think OOTP is good for historical stats over several seasons and plays the ‘what if’ scenario really well. As far as season replays I favor Strat.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

I'll have a look at it. OOTP looks great but Id be willing to check something else out. Do you know if stratomatic lets you play a friend online?

[Steven547]

Re: baseball sims

I hear mixed reviews on OOTP vs Strat-O-Matic. Was wondering which has the better overall game play along with stats.

[tinpanalley]

Re: baseball sims

I hear mixed reviews on OOTP vs Strat-O-Matic. Was wondering which has the better overall game play along with stats.

Wish I could try Strat-o-matic, I don't see a demo anywhere.

[Frostball]

Re: baseball sims

Been playing OOTP since 1999 it is a great game