What does NFL 2K5 have that Madden still doesn't have?

[coogrfan]

Can somebody please tell me why this thread isn't in the 2k forum where it belongs?

[i3man]

2 inches of dust?

[coogrfan]

Quote: Originally Posted by i3man

2 inches of dust?

OUCH!!!

We have a winner!

[Chitown1211]

#1 IMO is collision detection. It was stellar in 2K5. This games collision is like 5 years old. And really hurts the game.

Theres about a million other features presention wise and control wise , but who has the time to list all those. If you played 2K5 on the xbox you know Madden isnt even in the same ball park. Heck not even in the parking lot.

And online? Oh man . Dont get me started. For those that dont know. In 2K5 the online leagues were like fantasy leagues. Everything was there. You could TRADE players from team to team. Everything was online. STats, standings. And by online I mean on XBL. Not some 3rd party website. It was a REAL online league.


And for everyone saying " let it go" " move on". That wouldnt be a problem if Madden was implementing these basic things that we had on a game 3 years old on an old gen system. As long as EA keeps making a game in the NEXT GEN that doesnt even have the features of old gen games people will complain.

We shouldnt even be able to compare these two games. That alone shows how much Madden is lacking . We all know 2K5 had problems like any other game. It wasnt PERFECT, But that has NOTHING to do next gen Madden being so far behind a 3 year old game on a last gen system.

[Dienekes]

Quote: Originally Posted by i3man

2 inches of dust?

[NovaStar]

Quote: Originally Posted by dubplate

A bunch of people still crying for it. I feel bad for some of these people's future grandchildren. "When I was your age we had this game called NFL 2K5. It had just as many flaws as that Madden game but we overlooked them. The funny thing is we would never alow the people that enjoyed Madden to do the same."

Or those people with permanent smiles on their faces praising the mediocrity that is madden telling their grandchildren "stop crying, gang tackling and presentation will be in the game next year, after all it is a new engine, dont' worry madden 2066 will be better".

[MaddenMan]

NFL2K had online leagues and a cool halftime show and funny commentators. But honestly that doesn't make a break the game to me, they were just gravy items imo.

[fishepa]

PRESENTATION. The pre-game and halftime/postgame highlights and commentary were done so well in 2k5.