08-14-2007, 09:37 PM
|
#2
|
Banned
OVR: 30
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Chicago
Posts: 22,335
|
Re: Rate all 3 football games
NCAA- 6.5
APF- 7.5
Haven't played Madden yet.
NCAA's interception deal makes it unplayable to me. If this was fixed, it would move up to a mid 9 score, but it's just too big of an issue. Plus a few annoying details like the stupid fumble challenges and the fact that recruiting is no different than last year, just a lot more time consuming.
APF is a good football game, but just missing something for greatness. The lack of a multi-season dynasty is inexcusable. The getting on their knees to appease the NFL is pathetic in my opinion; if I want to name my team the Washington Redskins and draw a logo that looks exactly like it, let me. The lack of a name or logo editor is just very annoying. I also don't like how the game limits to the 2 gold, 3 silver, 6 bronze. I paid $60 for the game; if I want to make a team with Joe Montana, Jerry Rice, Barry Sanders, and 15 other gold players, why the hell can't I? Does it hurt any one? In every other sports game since the PS2/DC came out, I've been allowed to make a team with 99 everything. That's not my exact intentions, but it's in the realm.
|
|
|