Rate all 3 football games

[Sully]

I'm not going to get into details, but...

Madden - 8.5 (The game is just a blast to play this year. I'm not seeing the issues with turnovers...yet.)

NCAA - 7 (Too many INTs, and the button lag online drives me insane.)

APF - 6 (I have a love/hate relationship with this game. Gameplay is, for the most part, solid. Poor DB AI is still there. It's not as prevalent as 2k5, but it's there. Novelty of the legends wore off quickly with me, making the game boring.)

[Bizzy Da Kid]

Madden - 8.4

NCAA - 7.5

APF - 6.3

[NoleFan]

Not real good with number ratings so I'll just order then how I rank them this year.

Madden
All-Pro
.
NCAA

[TDKing]

APF - 8.54
Madden - 7.36
NCAA - 7.31

[newgen1]

APF 8.5
Madden 7.5
NCAA 7.5

[bkrich83]

I like all 3. Is that wrong?

[muggins]

NCAA 7 turnovers
APF 8
Madden - haven't played

[GoDawgs211]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

I like all 3. Is that wrong?

Not at all, I enjoy all three as well yet I like them for different reasons. I feel as though EA stepped it up this year yet I enjoy All Pro's gameplay and physics system a little more. In my opinion, there is nothing wrong with any of them, they are just different.