Madden 11 vs NCAA 11 post Tune -- INPUT NEEDED

[jzicc]

(I was going to throw BBRKER post patch in there but let's keep things simple)

not trying to start a flame war and PLEASE DELETE if I'm violating some tos or something ---

just trying to get what people are feeling out there from those that have played both ---

I'm sure others are out there trying to decide between the 2

[mestevo]

What do you primarily do w/ your football games? Competitive online? Franchise? Exhibition? As a franchise player BB can't even be compared to either, and NCAA looks to be superior to Madden.

From a gameplay perspective after only a couple of retail games of Madden, I'm leaning NCAA... something about the pacing of this years game feels off to me, maybe it will get better, but I was having more fun with NCAA.

[Jasong7777]

Loving Ncaa. Just got Madden so can't say much about it. So far so good. Backbreaker doesn't belong in this topic.

[Indian Joe]

NCAA is teh best

[jzicc]

Quote: Originally Posted by mestevo

What do you primarily do w/ your football games? Competitive online? Franchise? Exhibition?

realistic single player games (and non-online multliplayer) and franchise/dynasty are my main thoughts on what I'm asking

[RoyalBoyle78]

Well, I own both and I will say this, I think NCAA crushes MADDEN this year, yes crushes. NCAA just feels right, like the team took there time and brought the game back to it's roots, and that's the roots to great game making in the College game. I'm not saying Madden is not good, it;s just not better then NCAA IMO.


Another thing that just baffles me, NCAA graphics are really that much better then Madden, can't understand this. I mean player molds in NCAA just look so much better then what Madden offers this year.

I'm not going to really go any deeper, but bottom line is, NCAA is BACK!!!!! It is better then Madden IMO but a lot this year.

[jzicc]

Thanks FF -- means a lot coming from you