Madden?? or NCAA?? What game you pick..

[Matt23134]

Quote: Originally Posted by Nims4353

that is the single most idiotic reason i can think of the deprive yourself of an excellent game. Wow. Your reasoning process is seriously flawed.

Also, didn't the fans vote for Hillis to be on the cover?

[inkcil]

PS3:
After playing ncaa retail and madden demo, madden's graphics and weightier feel to the players is superior, imo. I returned ncaa after a week and i think i'll pick up a used copy of madden next month...

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Absolutely Madden. NCAA just had too many problems with their game this year, and franchise mode looks legit in Madden.

[illwill10]

Both. As a Offline Gamer only, I am excited to play Madden
NCAA- Really like NCAA 12. But, I think I will play Madden more. I have yet to play Dynasty waiting for the patch. I think Madden's Offline modes are more in depth than NCAA. Besides Coaching Carousel, there werent too many improvement to Dynasty. Being Limited to 5 min Quarters in RTG, really prevented me from having alot of fun and prevented me from playing a few positions. I only played RTG so far waiting for the patch.

Madden- I feel Franchise will be deeper than Dynasty. Improved Draft Logic, Rookie Scouting, DPP, Alot of HC 09 Additions, Traits and Player Roles. Biggest for me is Player Editing for all teams. No more Rookies coming over 85, especially under the 3rd round. I will still use NCAA classes. Besides being the Auto-Starter in Superstar, I feel it MIGHT be deeper. Coordinator Audio, Walk-on to teams, Trade Request, Custom Quarter Lengths, More Positions to play(TE,OL K/P).

I will use NCAA for Draft Classes and SS imports. But, I am a person who gets bored quickly. So I like to switch games and keep a rotation.