First off, thanks for your vote of confidence armyofone
And it's hard for me to comment and probably not appropriate for me to regarding beta testing (no I have not been a beta tester for this year's edition) - but I do know there is literally so many things they have to look at. For me, I have ONLY been looking at on-field game play to this point and merely scratched the surface with franchise (just having a look with how it operates this year -- and it's great btw, imho).
But honestly, know this -- if the v2.3 (launch version) was what we were left with, I wouldn't be playing the game and go into franchise -- it wasn't good enough for me (being a stat monkey and a realism freak, lol). HOWEVER, now at the v2.6 point which is where we are at as of this typing, I would honestly recommend the game, if you know what you are buying..and I would invest my time into franchise and really enjoy the game. Danny and crew are working very hard on it, and as of right now, it's very decent (and no, there is no sliders to tweak things - that is one thing that we are having Danny do for us as he continues to fine tune).
So bottom line -- it has progressed immensely over these three patches and is now pretty decent and fun (but still stuff to be cleaned up and fine tuned -- and they are also limited with a number of things with the current 3-D engine - not everything is going to be perfect and some things can't really be altered given that limitation -but the plan is to invest all profits to next year's version and upgrade the 3-D engine if the game sells well). But it is definitely worth buying and supporting in my opinion -- and seriously, the developers have exactly the right attitude towards consumers and feedback -- and they, as can be seen already, are extremely dedicated...and you won't get a developer here telling you that, "If you don't like it, build your own game"(unlike another game) - these guys are so far from that and are looking for feedback, ideas, and things to improve upon and fix.
And I understand your concern with the patching -- but to my knowledge, NO new issues/bugs have been created with the patches, and look at it this way - if you look at the NOW, v2.6 is miles better than v2.3. These guys are doing good things and definitely deserve support. It's only $20 and has a good franchise mode and is fun and pretty decent.
...now I have to go out of town for several days, but there is also some great guys advising and helping and giving feedback on the forums there (several of which have helped me with developing slider sets from Madden's PC past (armyofone above being one) - (we are like realism and stat freaks, lol) or from the old version (2006) of Maximum football, or indeed from Front Page Football Pro group. Get the game, have fun with it, and don't feel nervous about giving the developer feedback and suggestions -- it's a friendly bunch...plus we need more football alternatives.
I really like this one, it gets my seal of approval, and I hope you do too.
Happy Gaming
