Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

[sherrane]

#3 Michigan State (12-0) vs #1 Oregon (8-4) play in the Big Ten Championship Game. Michigan State beat Oregon in the season.

[jdb7623]

Re: Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

#3 Michigan State (12-0) vs #1 Oregon (8-4) play in the Big Ten Championship Game. Michigan State beat Oregon in the season.

No doubt. I have a theory on what is going on here. I believe the logic is teams are being HEAVILY rewarded for winning games against highly ranked teams. So check Oregon's schedule and see who they beat. They may have beat a bunch of top ranked teams whil State has less big wins. In other words wins are much more rewarded vs. Losses

[tdogg097]

Re: Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

I had a season that finished like this.

1. Michigan 12-0
2. Notre Dame 10-2
3. Alabama 12-0

Those rankings would only happen in a video game world. The poll logic is severely flawed. The lame thing is it only takes a few tests to realize how wrong things are yet the people who actually get paid to do this can't discover the problem.

[BonesKnows85]

Re: Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

Dynasty mode is a total unplayable mess. Even in road the glory I just beat #3 Clemson on the road and I’m 3-0 and not even ranked. Nothing close to realism.

The game needs major work in poll logic, sim logic, mass subs, and editability of fake players. Custom conferences is an absolute disaster. The issues shouldn’t be as bad when a game is worked on for years.

[trevdawg0909]

Re: Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

I'm in year 2 of my SJSU Dynasty.

Here's the CFP top 5 rankings in the nation at the end of the season (pre-playoff)

1. Georgia ...... 9-3
2. Ohio State .. 9-3
3. Oregon ....... 9-3
4. Oklahoma State ..... 8-4
5. Oklahoma ....... 12-0

Now tell me how an undefeated Sooners team gets ranked below an 8-4 OK State team?

In no way does this make any sense
And no Oklahoma didn't just play scrub teams. They won every game, so obviously they won every conference game.

[Locke888]

Re: Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

Someone tell me they have confirmed they are going to fix this in an upcoming patch…

I don’t want to start a serious dynasty until it’s done

[dahlzy19]

Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

Oofta, might be one of the worst ones I’ve seen. This needs a fix asap


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Locke888]

Re: Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

Wins and losses are literally 90% of the equation. It’s baffling.

[fightingirish595]

Re: Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

Unacceptable for this not to be ironed out pre release. Especially when they apparently spent so much time around the committee for ranking logic?

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

FSU says ''I feel your pain. Feel my pain too.''

[noarmsduck]

Re: Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

Found this one on EA forums

[GoDucks1224]

Re: Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

I’m loving the gameplay of this game. But I gotta say. How in the hell did any of this get passed QC? Like did no one on the team simulate a season in dynasty? Or did they think this is acceptable? Kinda wild.

[theoriginal561]

Re: Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

Found this one on EA forums

I have so many questions and I just don't even want to know. Also worth noting that even if a team upsets a top 10 opponent in the Conference Championship game they won't even move up more than a few spots. Had Miami #19 beat #5 Alabama by 3 scores and Miami moved up 2 spots and Alabama dropped 2 spots and guess who made the playoffs? Right, only Alabama. That makes 0 sense. Miami at least should have made it as a 12 seed.or Alabama falls out with 3 losses. I honestly don't think this is getting fixed.


AND in the same bracket, Ohio State ranked #12 with a 12-1 record and BIG 10 champ, stayed at 12 while Michigan who was 11-1 got the #3 seed and neither team played each other in the regular season. Ohio State was #2 and just dropped to 12 after the only loss 6 weeks prior.

[Collegefbfan]

Re: Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

Someone mentioned custom conferences being messed up. When I started my dynasty, I wanted to change some things around. Glad I didn't.

[EUBlink]

Re: Nothing says the rankings are messed up like this

I agree, sherrane, your rankings in that image look completely upside down.


I'll see myself out.