Gold, Silver, or Bronze? (game)
 

Moderators, please lock this if you feel this is just a post-pumping kind of thread.


The game is very simple, but the execution may be a little tough. Basically, a poster calls out a name or set of names out of the legends that are in the game, more or less because they are unsure about which ranking you think they will receive in this game. The next reply would be what they think how they are ranked, and then they will ask a question about a player as well. For example, if I were to start out and say "Jerry Rice", the next user would say "Gold", and then ask for "Barry Sanders". It keeps going on. The thing is, let's try and go for the players that you don't know what their rank will be.

During this time, I will keep this post updated on the list of players under Gold, Silver, and Bronze. When the game comes out, we can compare lists.

The tough part, aside from just labeling which one they fall under, is getting the correct distribution for each number of legends in either Gold, Silver, or Bronze. I suppose we can assume that the least number of players will be Gold (roughly around 45 or less), the second least will be Silver (65-ish), and the most will be Bronze... whatever is left (for now is 130). Now, this is no guarantee that these are the actual numbers, and if people can decide on a better three numbers, let me know what you think I should change them to.



Sound good? I'll start.

- Johnny Unitas
- Gary Plummer




__________________________________________________ ___________________________________________




Gold (12/45)

John Elway
Dan Marino
Joe Montana
Walter Payton
Andre Reed
Jerry Rice
Barry Sanders
O.J. Simpson
Mike Singletary
Jack Tatum
Thurman Thomas
Johnny Unitas



Silver (10/65)

Jerome Brown
Harry Carson
Gary Clark
Jim Marshall
Herman Moore
Lenny Moore
Drew Pearson
Gary Plummer
Gayle Sayers
Jessie Tuggle



Bronze (3/130)

Bubby Brister
Joe Theismann
Andre Ware

Re: Gold, Silver, or Bronze? (game)
 

Johnny U = Gold - forgive me only Bmore great in the game.
Plummer = Bronze maybe Silver hard to say I'm going to lean toward Silver. Bosworth is Bronze and Plummer was better than Boz easily.


Gale Sayers
Harry Carson

Re: Gold, Silver, or Bronze? (game)
 

Gayle Sayers-Silver(VERY debatable but they have so many great RB's)
Harry Carson-Silver



Lenny Moore

Re: Gold, Silver, or Bronze? (game)
 

Gold:
Walter Payton
Barry Sanders
Dan Marino
Joe Montana
Jerry Rice
John Elway
OJ Simpson

Plastic:
Andre Ware

Re: Gold, Silver, or Bronze? (game)
 

Ahhh I forgot about Moore as a Bmore great. I'm going to put Moore in the Silver category.

Jessie Tuggle


Bubby Brister

Re: Gold, Silver, or Bronze? (game)
 

He's not even on the podium



What about Theismann?

Re: Gold, Silver, or Bronze? (game)
 

Theismann? I'll go with Bronze

What about Drew Pearson?

Re: Gold, Silver, or Bronze? (game)
 

Pearson=Silver
Tuggle=Silver

Andre Reed and Thurman Thomas?