BE Honest- NCAA 08 is better and you Know It!
 

Come on People, Tell me I am wrong? I just traded in Madden 08 for the 360, and feel pretty good about it. After playing several seasons with Madden, I can safely say this feels tremendously different than NCAA 08. I realize this is the Pro game, but usually the two titles feel somewhat similar. Funny thing is, when I traded in the game, the manager at Gamespot confirmed my suspicions and stated Madden has been traded in at an extremely alarming Rate.

Re: BE Honest- NCAA 08 is better and you Know It!
 

Thanks for telling us?

Re: BE Honest- NCAA 08 is better and you Know It!
 

If Madden is worse than NCAA, it must be a complete waste of time - NCAA's many bugs are terrible; game-killing for lots of people.

Re: BE Honest- NCAA 08 is better and you Know It!
 

I feel no need to choose because I play and enjoy both.

Plus, I never understood why people would trade in a game after playing it for a month. I saw that Gamestop had a special discount if you traded in NCAA 08 towards Madden, and I couldn't believe people would actually do that. Guess I was wrong!

Then, to top it off, when the hype stops bubbling about 09, you'll see people on here who go out and re-buy the very game they traded in. Huge waste of money IMO.

Re: BE Honest- NCAA 08 is better and you Know It!
 

Honestly, no, I don't know it. I find Madden to be much more enjoyable. Madden feels much more polished than NCAA. NCAA feels like I'm playing a 70% build of Madden. Sure they both have their turnover problems, but of the two, I prefer Madden.

Re: BE Honest- NCAA 08 is better and you Know It!
 

Well I think NCAA is more fun. That's how I tell what game is better - which one is more fun for me. NCAA used to be my favorite, then it was a lot worse than Madden. Now, NCAA is more fun again in my opinion and therefore the better game.

Re: BE Honest- NCAA 08 is better and you Know It!
 

Gotta agree with the OP. I much prefer NCAA, although it seems every year I much prefer NCAA. Madden just feels to "gimmicky" with all the weapons, and ring building, and stuff. Sure, there are definitely some nice aspects of Madden (mini-games, stadium builder, draft) but for me, I am getting a TON of enjoyment from NCAA.

My feelings may change once the NFL season kicks off. It seems that on Saturdays all I want to play is NCAA, and on Sundays its all about Madden. Good thing I have (and am keeping) both...

Re: BE Honest- NCAA 08 is better and you Know It!
 

Both are good but with my patch yeah it's better;)