Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

[ProfessaPackMan]

Who's your top 10?

[shnuskis]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

1. Peyton Manning
2.Tom Brady

one and two interchangable.

3.Drew Brees
4.Kurt Warner
5.Carson Palmer
6.Big Ben R.
7.Matt Hasselbeck
8.Aaron Rodgers
9.Phillip Rivers
10. Matt Ryan

[Derrville]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

P.Manning
Brady
Roethlisberger
Brees
Romo
Warner
Rivers
Mcnabb
Palmer
E. Manning


No order.

[JBH3]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady (if returning to full health)
3. Drew Brees
4. Donovan McNabb
5. Big Ben
6. Eli Manning
7. Kurt Warner
8. Carson Palmer (if returning to full health)
9. Jay Cutler
10. Chad Pennington/Aaron Rodgers

[JBH3]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

1. Peyton Manning
2.Tom Brady

one and two interchangable.

3.Drew Brees
4.Kurt Warner
5.Carson Palmer
6.Big Ben R.
7.Matt Hasselbeck
8.Aaron Rodgers
9.Phillip Rivers
10. Matt Ryan

No Eli? Cutler purposely left out? Ryan in the top 10? Hasselbeck in the top 10?

[HungryBologna]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

Brady
Peyton
Big Ben
Rivers
Cutler
Palmer
Brees
Eli
Warner
Mcnabb

[OSUFan_88]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

Brady
Payton
McNabb
Brees
Big Ben
Rivers
Romo
Eli
Warner
Cutler

[N51_rob]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

Not thinking about it, just going off the top of my head.

Brady
Big Manning
Lil' Manning
McNabb
Brees
Rivers
Big Ben
Rodgers
Cutler


I can only do 9. I had to stop or I would've tried to justify my homerness and put my guy up there.

[ezekiel55]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

Tom Brady
Peyton
Brees
Rivers
Roethlisberger
Mcnabb
Warner
Eli
Cutler
Aaron Rodgers

[Hooe]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

Brady
Manning
Roethlisberger
McNabb
Brees
Rivers
Warner
Romo
Palmer
Rodgers

[Alliball]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady (if returning to full health)
3. Drew Brees
4. Donovan McNabb
5. Big Ben
6. Eli Manning
7. Kurt Warner
8. Carson Palmer (if returning to full health)
9. Jay Cutler
10. Chad Pennington/Aaron Rodgers

Interestingly enough you're the only one to leave Rivers off their list yet you're calling out another poster's list.

[SportsTop]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

Interestingly enough you're the only one to leave Rivers off their list yet you're calling out another poster's list.

I saw that too.

This place is comical. If nothing else, Rivers belongs on this list before Cutler could even sniff it.

[wwharton]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

1. Peyton Manning
2.Tom Brady

one and two interchangable.

3.Drew Brees
4.Kurt Warner
5.Carson Palmer
6.Big Ben R.
7.Matt Hasselbeck
8.Aaron Rodgers
9.Phillip Rivers
10. Matt Ryan

I like this list (not necessarily in this order) but I'd put in McNabb instead of Ryan. Both Ryan and Flacco don't deserve to be in any top 10 yet.

I'd say Hasselbeck/Palmer/Cutler are fighting for two spots... I take the first two if both are healthy based on what they've done to this point.

I know some will argue with Rivers and Rodgers over Cutler but adding all things including being in the same system they've been in for years. Also want to add that Romo is on this edge too... need to see how he looks without TO.

[shnuskis]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

I like this list (not necessarily in this order) but I'd put in McNabb instead of Ryan. Both Ryan and Flacco don't deserve to be in any top 10 yet.

I'd say Hasselbeck/Palmer/Cutler are fighting for two spots... I take the first two if both are healthy based on what they've done to this point.

I know some will argue with Rivers and Rodgers over Cutler but adding all things including being in the same system they've been in for years. Also want to add that Romo is on this edge too... need to see how he looks without TO.

I knew the big issue with my list was Romo and Mcnabb not being on the list. Mcnabb being in a situation to be benched last year is what kept him off the list. He played great after that and I won't argue with anyone who wants Mcnabb on the list. But a top 10 guy doesn't get benched.

Romo is just off the list also and I really like him. The question is out there about the ability to win the big game. He has proven to make mistakes in those big moments. That kept him off my list. The same argument can be made of Rodgers, but HIS play was really good late in games. It was the defense that lost close games.

I like Hasselbecks veteran leadership.

Love what Matt Ryan did in Atlanta proving how much better he is than Mike Vick. Excellent leader on the field, poised, and made the right reads. I think he deserves it.

[wwharton]

Re: Top 10 Quarterbacks in the League.

I knew the big issue with my list was Romo and Mcnabb not being on the list. Mcnabb being in a situation to be benched last year is what kept him off the list. He played great after that and I won't argue with anyone who wants Mcnabb on the list. But a top 10 guy doesn't get benched.

Romo is just off the list also and I really like him. The question is out there about the ability to win the big game. He has proven to make mistakes in those big moments. That kept him off my list. The same argument can be made of Rodgers, but HIS play was really good late in games. It was the defense that lost close games.

I like Hasselbecks veteran leadership.

Love what Matt Ryan did in Atlanta proving how much better he is than Mike Vick. Excellent leader on the field, poised, and made the right reads. I think he deserves it.

That game was against the Ravens so I know it VERY well. McNabb didn't play that bad before being benched. Considering it was against the Ravens D, I'd say he played about average actually. The benching was more of a statement than anything else, and obviously it was a bad statement. Besides that, he led his team to what, 4 NFC championships in a row and one SB appearance (with help from Garcia when he was hurt)? With so much service time, I don't think it'd be fair to look at just last year to judge him anyway... and if we did then Hasselbeck and Palmer need to be removed from the list.