Redshirt a Senior???
 

A question has come up in one of my ODs, so I thought I would get a consensus here. If you redshirt a senior will they leave anyway, thus wasting his senior year?

Re: Redshirt a Senior???
 

I remember trying this a few years ago back on the PS2. They left at the end of the season.

So unless it's changed, and I'm assuming it hasn't, don't do it.

Re: Redshirt a Senior???
 

If you redshirt a senior, he'll just be a redshirt senior the next year.

I had the dilemma of redshirting Keiland Williams for LSU in our yearly OD so that I'd have a legitamate every down back next year while I get another back for the future.

Re: Redshirt a Senior???
 

Keeping to "Sim" as close as possible anyone know if this has ever happened in real life, on any team? Excluding a medical redshirt of course.

Re: Redshirt a Senior???
 

A senior would never be redshirted unless it was for NCAA violations or Medical redshirt. If your trying to be as 'sim' as possible, it shouldn't be allowed.

Re: Redshirt a Senior???
 

Other then medical the only time I can remember is WKU did it when they made the jump to FBS. They played UGA the year before that full time jump and they had a few guys that they set out that were jr & sr. But to just red shirt I would say only medical. I have done it before but I don't aim for "sim" since it is a video game.

Re: Redshirt a Senior???
 

only reason to do it so you can have a better team next season... like if you have a 1 star school and you have a sr hb or wr and everything else sucks i would

Re: Redshirt a Senior???
 

Or if a player changes position...

Take for example Sam Shields (The U)

He was a WR fresh-jr year...Shannon asked him to move to CB...he did...

rumor had it if he didn't pick up D quick enough, he was going to redshirt this year...meaning he will be a Senior (RS)