Which RB would you keep?

[skudplayr]

I'm in year 10 of my Raiders franchise and I'm into the offseason. I've been running the dual RB system basically the entire chise and for the last four years I've had these two guys handling the load. However, my team's coming off a loss in the Super Bowl (have yet to win one, gone to 4 AFC Championships and lost three, then lost the Super Bowl the one year I made it). They are both FA and I have a tough decision on my hands as to who to resign. I only want to bring back one because I don't have the financial flexibility to bring both back. Here is their info (I'm leaving out their name to avoid any draft class spoilers).

HB #20 - 6'1", 215 lbs, 88 OVR, B POT, 26 Years old
- 97 SPD, 89 AGI, 96 ACC, 85 AWR, 96 TRK, 87 ELU, 66 BCV, 90 Stiff Arm, 75 Sp. move, 78 juke, 88 CAR, 42 CTH, 85 INJ
- Career Stats - 1035 Att, 4580 yards, 29 TD, 4.4 YPC, 54 Rec, 638 Yards, 3 TD
- 2018 Stats - 203 Att, 1068 yards, 8 TD, 5.2 YPC, 10 Rec, 97 yards
- Contract Demands: 6 years, $41.9 million, $16.74 million bonus


HB #49 - 6'1, 219 lbs, 87 OVR, B POT, 25 Years old
- 87 SPD, 95 AGI, 92 ACC, 83 AWR, 94 TRK, 83 ELU, 83 BCV, 84 Stiff Arm, 87 Sp. move, 81 juke, 76 CAR, 69 CTH, 76 INJ
- Career Stats - 392 Att, 1713 yards, 7 TD, 4.3 YPC
- 2018 Stats - 130 Att, 575 yards, 2 TD, 4.4 YPC
- Contract Demands - 6 years, $35.88 million, $14.34 million bonus

[xblake16x]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

i would personally choose #20, he has been able to carry the load. A better ypc, and a higher/better injury rating.

[klo626]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

depends on your play i like speedier backs so personally i would choose #20

[skudplayr]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

I forgot to add in that #49 is also my kick returner and he has 4 career return touchdowns including a 74 yard return in the Super Bowl that set up a touchdown.

It's a tough decision.

[tyronebiggums]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

keep #20, then draft one with A potential

[FedExPope]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

I'd go with #20. Better carry and injury ratings, proven himself worthy of his contract demands.

[skudplayr]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

Well, I decided to go with #20. He was awarded with a fat 6 year contract. I just hope the other guy doesn't sign with a rival and then tear me apart. It's already happened twice with other players I didn't resign haha.

[skudplayr]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

keep #20, then draft one with A potential

I wish it were that easy. I don't use scouting and certainly won't look at one of the cheat sheets. I just draft based on their combine numbers and such.

[kenp86]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

#20, has betr carry rating

[skudplayr]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

I let #49 go and he signed with Houston.

Now, who am I playing in the following year's AFC Championship? Wouldn't you know it...Houston.

[Sportsbuck]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

Are you simming all your games?

[skudplayr]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

Yeah, except for big playoff games. Just a sim chise. I'm waiting until the patch and roster update #2 to start my actual playing chise.

[NFLFAN]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

number 20

[stlstudios189]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

good choice with #20 man. I was wondering how the heck you were 10 season in man. I like seeing my former players come back and play against me.

[skudplayr]

Re: Which RB would you keep?

Ha, yeah well we lost to them in the Conference Title game. Now, I'm in a rebuilding mode after 10 years of trying to win a title. My franchise QB has gotten hurt back to back seasons and his rating went from a 94 to an 82. I had to ride it out with a 40 year old Carson Palmer last year but he retired. Now, I have a feeling I'm in for a few seasons of poor play.

Good news is that the RB that I resigned (#20) proved that he deserved the money with a career high 1600 yards and 10 TD. Too bad the rest of my team is just getting old and decrepid.