I've always been trying to get this to happen, but I have never been able to get a TD either called back or score a TD because of an official replay review. Sometimes when I get really close to a TD, I try and get a replay on the spot of the ball hoping to overturn it and call it a TD, but it has never happen. Also, maybe they call a WR out of bounds on a TD catch but then review having it overturned and called a TD, never had it happen. Anyone else? Is this even possible?
-
-
Re: has anyone ever had a TD called off of a replay review?
On those close plays the refs converse about it anyways, so it does it's own review and gives you the answer. I don't believe you can challenge after that ref conversation cut scene. -
Re: has anyone ever had a TD called off of a replay review?
I had one once play with the Lions @ GB. Megatron caught a lob in the back corner of the endzone and it was called a TD, but the booth reviewed it before i could kick the XP and it was called back (and the review showed it should have been)HELLO BROOKYLN.
All Black EverythingComment
-
Re: has anyone ever had a TD called off of a replay review?
I have had a few where i get a diving catch in the end zone. The receiver's full body is in the end zone the whole time, but then they review it and i get the ball at the 1 instead.Comment
-
Re: has anyone ever had a TD called off of a replay review?
Yea, I have had that happen where I have my WR entire body in the endzone and they call it at the 1 yard line. But I have never had a review where they call it at the 1 then I review and then they call it a TD.Comment
-
Re: has anyone ever had a TD called off of a replay review?
Saw this once:
CPU throws for a TD back of the end zone - referee cut scene comes up signaling touchdown - points added - TOUCHDOWN Flashes on screen...I was like no way, foot was out of bounds.
Under coaching options, Challenge Play was available, so I challenged and I won! TD overruled.Comment
-
Re: has anyone ever had a TD called off of a replay review?
There's no point in challenging ball spots. They will never get overturned. Madden needs a better ball spot and challenge system. I'm not sure if they can address that in a patch but it needs to happen in Madden 11.Chicago Bulls | Chicago Bears | Chicago White Sox | Chicago BlackhawksComment
-
Re: has anyone ever had a TD called off of a replay review?
Once, I threw a screen pass down near the goal line as the Steelers in a preseason game with a certain 7th round gem, he caught it, juked a guy, got stood up near the goaline and kinda pushed and shoved till he fell down on the one. The refs initially called it a TD, the team I was playing (can't remember who) challenged it, and they marked my guy on the 1. Of course I went on to score on the next play, but I thought it was pretty cool.Comment
-
Re: has anyone ever had a TD called off of a replay review?
I have seen plenty TDs called back but never had one turned into a TD after a close play though.*˙ǝɟıן ɹnoʎ ɟo spuoɔǝs ǝʌıɟ ʇsoן ʇsnɾ ǝʌɐɥ noʎ ʇɐɥʇ ʎɐs oʇ ʎɹɹos ɯɐ ı sıɥʇ pɐǝɹ noʎ ɟı
*Actual time may vary.Comment
-
Re: has anyone ever had a TD called off of a replay review?
I just had one today actually. I ran it up the middle with B. West and the refs conversed and called it a TD, but then the panthers threw the challenge flag out and it was reversed and the ball was placed on the one inch mark."Believe in Now"
RIP J.J.Comment
-
Re: has anyone ever had a TD called off of a replay review?
Yes i had a TD called back in my online franchise against another human opponent. The Giants were at the 10 yard line, down by 3 points with 0:15 left in the game and no timeouts left. We decided to give it one shot to the endzone for the score. I rolled out left with Manning and hit my receiver in the numbers. He was very quickly tackled and pushed back. At first he appeared to have scored a touchdown, but upon an automatic booth review the refs ruled him just shy of the goal line. What was worse was the clock then continued to run! I thought the clock stopped on challenges and booth reviews. Because of this i was unable to spike the ball and kick the game tying field goal. The game ended with my team slowly scrabling to line up for the next play. A bad way to end the game on a rule that i think has been botched in Madden. Shouldnt the clock have been stopped?
Comment
-
Re: has anyone ever had a TD called off of a replay review?
One time I wanted to challenge a CPU WR catch in the back corner, where I SWEAR neither foot was down in bounds.
the cutscene with the refs came up, and they talked and then gave it to the CPU.
I wanted to challenge, but the option to do so never came up! whats up with that?Comment
Comment