Vote time!!!! Better QB for rebuilding franchise?????
 

Which Qb would be a good and realistic pick for a rebuilding Raiders team????

Tarvaris Jackson

Graham Harrell

Vince Young

Troy Smith

Re: Vote time!!!! Better QB for rebuilding franchise?????
 

I personally like harrell but he probably doesn't have the arm to use the WR speed on the raiders squad. I would go with vince for that squad.

Re: Vote time!!!! Better QB for rebuilding franchise?????
 

Did they raise any of Vince's passing accuracy ratings in the last Roster Update? As a Texas fan, I have to say Vince Young. Did you see them try to tackle him Sunday night and he stood up the defenders! lol Little bit of jawing went on after that failed tackled attempt. I guess 6'4", 235 lbs isn't that easy to bring down when you tackle up top. Didn't realize he was so hard to bring down. No one every touched him in college... :)

Re: Vote time!!!! Better QB for rebuilding franchise?????
 

What is your philosophy going to be? Neither of those guys really strike me as the guy. Young, recently is starting to show the ability to get to his 2nd and 3rd receivers (irl) I don't know how that would translate to Madden, but it's Young or Jackson, depending on how much you plan to run the ball and what kind of throws you plan on having your QB make.

Re: Vote time!!!! Better QB for rebuilding franchise?????
 

my vote is for Young, but you might be better off building through the draft...

Re: Vote time!!!! Better QB for rebuilding franchise?????
 

I'm not loving any of the options. Why limit yourself to those four? You could either target a young QB in a trade (Sanchez, Stafford or even Kevin Kolb with the Eagles, for example) or just build through the draft (my preferred method).

Re: Vote time!!!! Better QB for rebuilding franchise?????
 

i love how peoples opinions of young have changed

before that monday night no1 would have said vince

but now everyone likes him again lol

Re: Vote time!!!! Better QB for rebuilding franchise?????
 

Troy Smith, he offers the most challenge.