My Thoughts on the Game

[Bender18]

Well I got this game simultaneously with Madden for Christmas and I must say, I have been playing this 80% of the time. After reading a lot of people bash this game on here, I was a little bit discouraged. But I'm glad I finally got it!

Sure, it has it's flaws, but with the right sliders it's an awesome game. And I love the recruiting. In my opinion, it's a much better system than what Madden has going on with scouting and then the draft. It's really cool to see the players you recruited coming up through the ranks and eventually contributing to the team.

I just wanted to write this to give people some hope about the game!

[canes21]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

I've had this since release and have had Madden since release. I am still playing this everyday. Madden once a week sometimes more. Madden has the flash, but this has the gameplay. I don't see players breaking records every year like in Madden. The stats are pretty good, and the gameplay is fine for now. It definitely needs physics and momentum, but it beats Madden in gameplay IMO. My LB's actually get 7+ tackles a game in NCAA too while in Madden my LBS add up to 7 tackles a game between all 3 of them.

[jbrew2411]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

I have had both since release and play this game way more. I like the way Madden plays though but it gets boring. The speed is the big thing for me with this game . It plays fast and player speed mean nothing. This game is getting better and it looks like EA is going to make some changes to the dynasty mode which is a good thing. Its a good game and offers some fun times with the right sliders. The ones that are bashing the game I think forget that it is a video game and will never be like what we see on tv on Saturday's.

[dp68]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

The Defensive Pass Coverage is Garbage. It has been garbage since the first few years of the series, and it still is. I ignored the series for 4 years before trying 2010 out. What a waste of money.

I played this game for 3 days and threw my hands up in frustration. Mind you I was playing in "coach mode," and not cheesing.

I found that the defense could not cover Slant plays no matter who the teams were. I was coaching Florida Atlantic against Florida, and beat them in 8 min quarters in All-American mode 49-42. I just called Slant Pass after Slant Pass and they couldn't stop a single one. My QB completed something like 40 of 44 passes for over 500 yards.

So I tried with different teams, and got the same ridiculous results. I changed the sliders, and Slant passes still burned every defense.

In one particularly amazing moment, I got bored of "outsmarting" the defense by calling slant passes. I was facing 3rd and about 25 from my own 30 yard line, and I decided to call "Verticals." All receivers raced down the field past the secondary like they were standing knee deep in water. Then my QB threw a strike to a wide open receiver who went for the TD. On my next possession, I decided to call "Verticals" again. Guess what? 80 yard TD pass. Are you kidding me?

Finally I lowered the QB Accuracy to 10, and increased the Def Pass Coverage to 80. This lowered Slant Pass Completion %'s to about 60%. But it effectively killed all other pass plays from working. What a joke. Did anyone over the age of 12 play test this game?

Nice graphics. Great for kids I guess. But if you know a little about football, this game will challenge you for about 5 minutes.

[canes21]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

Slants don't work like you say. I run with SMU in an online dynasty with my friends and we're in year two. I may have maybe thrown 30 slant passes all dynasty long due to the fact they don't work too great for my team. And the CPU used to run slants al over me, but I decided to run zone when I saw slant patters start to appear. Guess what. They threw a pick, then an incomplete. They never went back to the slant the rest of the game.

This is my summary.

NCAA - Does a good job of what play works against certain D's. It doesn't always look realistic, but gets realistic results.

Madden - Looks somewhat realistic, but isn't really always realistic results.

[nikpin]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

The Defensive Pass Coverage is Garbage. It has been garbage since the first few years of the series, and it still is. I ignored the series for 4 years before trying 2010 out. What a waste of money.

I played this game for 3 days and threw my hands up in frustration. Mind you I was playing in "coach mode," and not cheesing.

I found that the defense could not cover Slant plays no matter who the teams were. I was coaching Florida Atlantic against Florida, and beat them in 8 min quarters in All-American mode 49-42. I just called Slant Pass after Slant Pass and they couldn't stop a single one. My QB completed something like 40 of 44 passes for over 500 yards.

So I tried with different teams, and got the same ridiculous results. I changed the sliders, and Slant passes still burned every defense.

In one particularly amazing moment, I got bored of "outsmarting" the defense by calling slant passes. I was facing 3rd and about 25 from my own 30 yard line, and I decided to call "Verticals." All receivers raced down the field past the secondary like they were standing knee deep in water. Then my QB threw a strike to a wide open receiver who went for the TD. On my next possession, I decided to call "Verticals" again. Guess what? 80 yard TD pass. Are you kidding me?

Finally I lowered the QB Accuracy to 10, and increased the Def Pass Coverage to 80. This lowered Slant Pass Completion %'s to about 60%. But it effectively killed all other pass plays from working. What a joke. Did anyone over the age of 12 play test this game?

Nice graphics. Great for kids I guess. But if you know a little about football, this game will challenge you for about 5 minutes.

Yea this is a pretty sad post. Play me online and we'll see how well 4 verticals and slants work. It's called adjusting coverages!

[jbrew2411]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

The Defensive Pass Coverage is Garbage. It has been garbage since the first few years of the series, and it still is. I ignored the series for 4 years before trying 2010 out. What a waste of money.

I played this game for 3 days and threw my hands up in frustration. Mind you I was playing in "coach mode," and not cheesing.

I found that the defense could not cover Slant plays no matter who the teams were. I was coaching Florida Atlantic against Florida, and beat them in 8 min quarters in All-American mode 49-42. I just called Slant Pass after Slant Pass and they couldn't stop a single one. My QB completed something like 40 of 44 passes for over 500 yards.

So I tried with different teams, and got the same ridiculous results. I changed the sliders, and Slant passes still burned every defense.

In one particularly amazing moment, I got bored of "outsmarting" the defense by calling slant passes. I was facing 3rd and about 25 from my own 30 yard line, and I decided to call "Verticals." All receivers raced down the field past the secondary like they were standing knee deep in water. Then my QB threw a strike to a wide open receiver who went for the TD. On my next possession, I decided to call "Verticals" again. Guess what? 80 yard TD pass. Are you kidding me?

Finally I lowered the QB Accuracy to 10, and increased the Def Pass Coverage to 80. This lowered Slant Pass Completion %'s to about 60%. But it effectively killed all other pass plays from working. What a joke. Did anyone over the age of 12 play test this game?

Nice graphics. Great for kids I guess. But if you know a little about football, this game will challenge you for about 5 minutes.

I have to say you are wrong. The pass coverage is not top notich but with the right sliders it can be good. I happen to know a little about football (high school coach with a state ring) and this game is not like real life football but that is becuase it is a video game. With that said it is a fun game that is worth playing. I have played this game since 98 and love the game. But I know it is a video game and look at it as nothing more. Sports games are a way for fans of a school/team to make them winners even if they suck in real life. I don't want the game to look like the same thing I watch on Saturday's and Sundays' or even Friday nights. Its a video game and nothing more. When will people see that and stop wanting it to be real life football.

[da ThRONe]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

This game is way to fast. You cant make moves even with guys with AGI in the high 90's. Playing one team feel the same as every other team. The option is useless. Player move so unrealistic. This game is subpar at best.

[z Revis]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

I actually traded in Madden to get this game. I didn't want to get rid of Madden, but at the same time I wanted this game. Last year I played NCAA 09 way more than Madden. And while Madden is a lot better this year, IMO, I still figured NCAA 10 would get more playing time from me. And it has. I'm not regretting my decision to trade Madden in one bit. This is a fun game. And honestly, that's all I ask for from video games. Sure it has it's problems, and sure I've complained about some of them, but it all comes down to having fun and I'm certainly enjoying NCAA Football 10.

[Bender18]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

I have found the coverage to be pretty good with decent sliders as well. And of course... it is just a video game. Sure, the stats might not always be like they are in real life, but it's still fun.

And there are certain things you can do in this game to have a slight advantage over the computer. But if you show some restraint and mix your playcall up, the game plays amazingly well.

[dp68]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

Yea this is a pretty sad post. Play me online and we'll see how well 4 verticals and slants work. It's called adjusting coverages!

You didn't read the post from start to finish, or you didn't comprehend. You tell me?

As stated, I was in "coach mode." The whole point is that the cpu defense doesn't adjust its coverages, and no matter what play it calls, it can't stop slants and verticals because the secondary doesn't know how to cover.

Sad response on your part. Read the post first. Then respond.

[dp68]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

I have to say you are wrong. The pass coverage is not top notich but with the right sliders it can be good. I happen to know a little about football (high school coach with a state ring) and this game is not like real life football but that is becuase it is a video game.

According to the promotion, it's realistic. Which is clearly misinformation.

Well I just coached Army to a 59-47 win over Auburn using 8 minute quarters. Called slant after slant, threw a few verticals for easy touchdowns. And Army is a run-option team with a terrible QB and WR set.

What I find truly disheartening is how many people are defending this horrible AI. It's not a fun game if a 5 year old can exploit it. It's 2010. How about expecting some decent AI from the most powerful software gaming company on the planet? For crying out loud, FPS Pro has been gone for 12 years and EA still can't approach its sophistication.

[Playmakers]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

This is by far my favorite sports game from last year. I'll be playing it until NCAA 11 is released

It's very close in terms of gameplay and animations to NCAA 06 which was my favorite version even til this day.

[prototype561]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

Yeah people know thats its a videogame, but the problem is that every year most videogames at least try get more realistic, most know that perfect realism will never happen but at least try. This forum is based of many hardcore sim base gamers who want to call an actual game of football. The NG Ncaa series makes me wonder if dev team really knows the x's and o's of football.

How can a game that is all physics base not have physics. I mean that could be a start.

Maybe actually test the game b4 u release it.

Maybe watch a college or nfl game to see how that plays.

Bingo we might have an real game of football. Its a game chess not checkers.

[JAYMO76]

Re: My Thoughts on the Game

[quote=Playmakers;2040628600]This is by far my favorite sports game from last year. I'll be playing it until NCAA 11 is released

It's very close in terms of gameplay and animations to NCAA 06 which was my favorite version even til this day.[/quote]


Yes it is by far the best next gen but I would never refer to it in the same category of 06... still the greatest football game ever!!!