Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

[TheBrew101]

Ok, I've tried to follow this board and the posts with a pretty high degree of scrutiny. I loved MLB09 and still play it (played every game into August). I kind of hate to give up on it with all the time I invested but it sounds like after the patch, MLB10 is the real deal.

That being said, I'm trying to figure out what the problems with the game are post patch #2. I'm basically just a franchise guy and don't mess with the other modes.

The one "bug" that I've read in a few threads is that there is a problem with the amateur draft in Franchise Mode causing too many highly rated pitchers and not enough position players which "ruins" franchise mode. Is this true? Has this been tested and proven or is it it false information? Does it happen every season?

Trying to decide if I should upgrade and this is a major issue for me since I can still have fun continuing my MLB09 franchise that I've invested tons of hours into (but like most everyone, I'd rather have the best game possible).

So any insight would be appreciated. I know from following threads that sometimes information isn't always correct or gets jumbled in with a ton of other topics so I'm trying to get a handle on this issue. Thank you.

[bxgoods]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

It depends how much you like building your team through the draft. If your a big draft person then it will make it hard for you to enjoy franchise mode.

[Knight165]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

How many pitchers do you usually see in the draft?
Total?

M.K.
Knight165

[TheBrew101]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

I don't know. I only have MLB09 and only did one draft on that one. If I wouldn't have read about the issue in these forums I wouldn't know it to be a problem (if it is). I'm guessing there are 60-90 pitchers in a draft? (Pure guess but I would suspect that every team could draft at least 2 pitchers).

But if almost all the pitchers are coming out with "A" potential and throwing off the balance then I think it is a major issue. I don't know if that is the case (I don't have MLB10 and that is what I'm trying to determine with this thread). Has anyone tested this issue enough to know if the draft really is truly consistently "broken"?

[bxgoods]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

Its discussed here
http://www.operationsports.com/forum...prospects.html

The draft is generating A potential Pitchers at a much higher rate than position players.
In my franchise 27 A potential SP's came out one year.

[TheBrew101]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

Thanks, that must have been the thread I read that had me scared.

So the issue wasn't addressed in patch #2 right? And it sounds like this is a problem with every draft and not just a random issue? No fix except for the one suggested (which I don't think it is a good one-i.e. changing drafted players to 45 years old so they retire)?

I'm surprised there isn't a major uproar about this issue. Unless maybe it doesn't play out to be a problem (thought that thread you referenced leads me to believe it may be a problem). Do all "A" rated potential pitchers turn out to be studs? Or do some of these guys flame out?

[CPT]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

Thanks, that must have been the thread I read that had me scared.

So the issue wasn't addressed in patch #2 right? And it sounds like this is a problem with every draft and not just a random issue? No fix except for the one suggested (which I don't think it is a good one-i.e. changing drafted players to 45 years old so they retire)?

I'm surprised there isn't a major uproar about this issue. Unless maybe it doesn't play out to be a problem (thought that thread you referenced leads me to believe it may be a problem). Do all "A" rated potential pitchers turn out to be studs? Or do some of these guys flame out?

Would it be better or more enjoyable if there were tons of A-level position players.... so there was little to no difference between any guy you draft or pick-up?

Yes, I know - ideally we all want a balance but it it were to be tipped in favor of one direction I would rather face several A-pitchers as opposed to a crapload of guys who should be stuck in AA ball.

while my experience may just be the exception to this "rule," I just had a draft (7 picks) where I grabbed 4 position players, three of which were A-grades, one B, while my pitchers were A,B,and F.

Furthermore, I know that guys do for a fact, have their potential grades changed as time goes on..... both up and down.

[bxgoods]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

Thanks, that must have been the thread I read that had me scared.

So the issue wasn't addressed in patch #2 right? And it sounds like this is a problem with every draft and not just a random issue? No fix except for the one suggested (which I don't think it is a good one-i.e. changing drafted players to 45 years old so they retire)?

I'm surprised there isn't a major uproar about this issue. Unless maybe it doesn't play out to be a problem (thought that thread you referenced leads me to believe it may be a problem). Do all "A" rated potential pitchers turn out to be studs? Or do some of these guys flame out?

I don't mind the fact if there's few high potential position players, I just would like some balance. Because the number of A potential pitchers you see in the minors borders on absurd by the 3rd season in franchise.

These are some SP rosters I see in my franchise. Nearly all the A and B potential pitchers are prospects from the draft, or were in the minors when with the current roster update.

[Cribbs]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

If there are way to many A rated Starting Pitchers, turn them into Relievers becuase the pool of young RP with high potential is low.

I like to play a year and use the Amatuer draft and put the names and ratings in after the first season, based on the actual draft. Like last year I drafted a A rated outfielder for the Pittsburgh Pirats but did a quick edit to make him a catcher and name him Tony Sanchez (The real first round draft pick of the Pirates).

I say take some SP and make them into RP or even closers. It would solve all your problems and A rated pitchers still may be high but now they are even throughout SP, RP an CL instead of a bunch of SP.

[bxgoods]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

If there are way to many A rated Starting Pitchers, turn them into Relievers becuase the pool of young RP with high potential is low.

I like to play a year and use the Amatuer draft and put the names and ratings in after the first season, based on the actual draft. Like last year I drafted a A rated outfielder for the Pittsburgh Pirats but did a quick edit to make him a catcher and name him Tony Sanchez (The real first round draft pick of the Pirates).

I say take some SP and make them into RP or even closers. It would solve all your problems and A rated pitchers still may be high but now they are even throughout SP, RP an CL instead of a bunch of SP.

I've seen a lot of A potential RP, and especially CP's in the draft.
Well I'm not so sure about RP, but I'm sure I've seen a lot of A potential CP's.

[CPT]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

Is it possiblr that people are reading a little too much into "potential?"

If the guy gets on the mound and gets lit up in half his starts are you going to kep him, because he "might" be good someday - while you toil in 3rd place...

[tessl]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

Unless there is some sort of completely new player development, the draft is broken. In my draft pool I have 50 top tier pitchers and 3 top tier position players. That's in addition to 5 A potential SP, 2 A potential RP and 1 A potential CP already on my minor league roster.

In another thread somebody simmed to 2016 and team budgets are messed up due to all the A potential pitchers.

My advice would be to wait to see if there is a patch on this before you dump '09 if you are enjoying it.

[findinghomer]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

Unless there is some sort of completely new player development, the draft is broken. In my draft pool I have 50 top tier pitchers and 3 top tier position players. That's in addition to 5 A potential SP, 2 A potential RP and 1 A potential CP already on my minor league roster.

In another thread somebody simmed to 2016 and team budgets are messed up due to all the A potential pitchers.

My advice would be to wait to see if there is a patch on this before you dump '09 if you are enjoying it.

what is it doing to the budgets? causing pitchers to be overpaid? if so could be a good thing to shrink buget room.

[CPT]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

Unless there is some sort of completely new player development, the draft is broken. In my draft pool I have 50 top tier pitchers and 3 top tier position players. That's in addition to 5 A potential SP, 2 A potential RP and 1 A potential CP already on my minor league roster.

In another thread somebody simmed to 2016 and team budgets are messed up due to all the A potential pitchers.

My advice would be to wait to see if there is a patch on this before you dump '09 if you are enjoying it.

so you are saying that in your current draft, there are 50 "A" pitchers available to draft?

Usually all the pitchers are gone by round 2 of every draft I have seen.

[tessl]

Re: Information--amatuer draft MLB10--bug?

so you are saying that in your current draft, there are 50 "A" pitchers available to draft?

Usually all the pitchers are gone by round 2 of every draft I have seen.

In my draft POOL that I am scouting there are 50 top tier pitchers and 3 top tier position players. As someone previously posted, this will make for a strange game in the future as when he simmed to 2016 the budgets were out of whack and there were a lot of free agent A potential pitchers because teams couldn't afford to sign them.

I'd like somebody to tell me what was wrong with last year's player potential and draft. I thought it was just fine.