Commentator Discussion Thread
 

I have heard and tend to agree that the commentating is getting a bit stale after years of the same commentating crew in The Show. So I beg the question:

Who would you want to commentate in MLB The Show 11'?



My vote goes for Joe Buck. I think he has an awesome voice for sporting events and whenever I hear him I know its either a big game or the game of the week. :star:

re: Commentator Discussion Thread
 

Chip Caray... j/k

re: Commentator Discussion Thread
 

Oh God no. Joe Buck is horrible. My vote is Vin Scully.

re: Commentator Discussion Thread
 

Vin Sculley was in the old MLB series. Get Tom Hamilton and Rick Manning. And don't even mention Hawk Harrelson and Steve Stone. Don't want to hear, " He gone!"

re: Commentator Discussion Thread
 

Man I have heard from many people they don't like him but I think he's the best broadcaster going. I know I may take some heat for this but Vin Scully has helped me out so much when i'm having a tough time falling asleep. I know he's "old-school standing around the radio listening to a baseball game" but i'm not much into him and I am a die-hard baseball purist. After second thought he would kinda be interesting in the game. Btw I also like the guy who does the Reds games ( can't think of his name) but I remember he used to be a prime-game broadcaster. I wonder what happened to him to get "demoted"?? Chip wouldn't be bad as you mention it ( I know it was a joke but I like the idea)

re: Commentator Discussion Thread
 

Anyone besides Hawk. Oh and nobody from
the SF team please.

re: Commentator Discussion Thread
 

The Uke!! Bob Uecker would be epic....

re: Commentator Discussion Thread
 

great idea man as an indians fan i have to agree with you a hundred percent