Found A "HUGE" Issue with Dynasty Recruiting

[MattUMD224]

And it involved the Quarterback position. I have simmed 4 years into dynasty to see how players are progressing (I edit my own rosters). I just went through every team to see how things are looking with the progression of the Re-Rated Quarterbacks and they are VERY VERY good. But the issue is teams recruitment of Quarterbacks. They are overflowing with them and these teams are only loading up on 5-7 OL per year.

1 QB-
2 QB-
3 QB- 20
4 QB- 27
5 QB- 34
6 QB- 18
7 QB- 10
8 QB- 6
9 QB- 4
10 QB- 1

The lower rated teams were not the only teams with lots of QB because of Walk-Ons. I saw numerous 4 Star teams having lots of Quarterbacks. Since we have tuning options I think this could be a easy thing to fix.

[Roggie]

Re: Found A "HUGE" Issue with Dynasty Recruiting

TEN quarterbacks on a team? You're kidding, right?

[dan_457]

Re: Found A "HUGE" Issue with Dynasty Recruiting

And it involved the Quarterback position. I have simmed 4 years into dynasty to see how players are progressing (I edit my own rosters). I just went through every team to see how things are looking with the progression of the Re-Rated Quarterbacks and they are VERY VERY good. But the issue is teams recruitment of Quarterbacks. They are overflowing with them and these teams are only loading up on 5-7 OL per year.

1 QB-
2 QB-
3 QB- 20
4 QB- 27
5 QB- 34
6 QB- 18
7 QB- 10
8 QB- 6
9 QB- 4
10 QB- 1

The lower rated teams were not the only teams with lots of QB because of Walk-Ons. I saw numerous 4 Star teams having lots of Quarterbacks. Since we have tuning options I think this could be a easy thing to fix.

Probably could be patched, but honestly, what are the odds they'll even touch this, i say 0%.

[dvdad]

Re: Found A "HUGE" Issue with Dynasty Recruiting

In last year's game I played a team in my dynasty that had literally 25 CB's with what appeared to be walk-ons at TE,OL,DL and LB. I doubt that it'll be fixed in a patch.

[MattUMD224]

Re: Found A "HUGE" Issue with Dynasty Recruiting

I'm doing another simulation now to see results.

[Whoman]

Re: Found A "HUGE" Issue with Dynasty Recruiting

this in general is part of the reason why the lower prestige teams really suck later on, i would expect a 3* QB to go a couple teams down on his list rather than signing with a team where he´s 7th on the depth chart.

In real life i think that Positions like QB and HB are actually filled with good players even at smaller programs, the problem starts in "depth-positions" like the Oline where they may have 1 or 2 serviceable guys but also 2 or 3 guys that are just totally outmatched on most nights.

a 1 or 2 star CPU controlled program in the game will basically never sign a 3 star player, i´d like for them to be able to "pick up the scraps" at the skills positions at least .

[rjsuperfly66]

Re: Found A "HUGE" Issue with Dynasty Recruiting

Sadly this is an important thing which hurts teams later on.

Your roster size is 70.

If you are developing 10 QBS, that means you are taking away 6-7 spots from developing other players.

Development is important (ie redshirt), so you don't just get a 60 rated freshman and have to throw him in your lineup.

[youALREADYknow]

Re: Found A "HUGE" Issue with Dynasty Recruiting

Please make sure this gets noticed by the NCAA devs. Things like this will kill replay value for all serious dynasty mode players.