Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

[mushyman167]

Which provides more realism and is a better complement to jd pro's sliders?

[BroMontana82]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

both sliders and rosters are personal preference. i'm a nogster fan myself but i think this is an objective overview of each: rashidi really scrutinizes every player in the league from the stars to the 15th man. his work on tendencies (which are huge) isn't very in depth. nogster really focuses on they key players rather than the 12th-15th man but his stats and in game experience are always on point as he looks at tendencies and ratings. he also goes through coach profiles as well so it's more of an overall experience, especially for association.

overall - rashidi for accurate ratings for every single player but not tendencies and nogster for on point tendencies, association experience, and ratings minus some of the scrubs. i think this is a fair assessment and even nogster would agree or admit as well.

glad both guys do this every year. everyone gets to choose to their liking.

[wrestlinggod1]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

I don't get why they don't bring their talents to OS and be on the same team..

[ggsimmonds]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

Nogster gets my vote because of Rashidi's arrogance and attitude.

[mushyman167]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

alright thx alot bromontana, i guess ill use nogsters cuz im looking for association and in game realism.

[gottibino]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

from what i've experienced from using both is that Nogsters are better by a photo finish for the simple fact that they work better after the first year of association (& work better w/ incoming rookies)
Both are incredible & the time these guys put in for us goes w/o saying. Big ups to both & greatly appreciated!

[Mike32Ownz]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

I'd tell ya if one of these guys made a roster for ps3...

[Tommyklaid]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

I'd tell ya if one of these guys made a roster for ps3...

Yep-

We're left in the dark...we need someone on our side.

[bobday]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

Theoretically Rashidi will release his this year for the PS3. Last year I was looking for the rosters uploaded by ffaacc03. I think that had something to do with Nogster.

[kpax1º1]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

I'd tell ya if one of these guys made a roster for ps3...

ffaacc03 is working on these.

[stateprop]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

I download both nogster and rashidi and combine them with DC edits. I combine nogster tendency with rashidi ratings with DC edits equals the best rosters ever. Goddammit first DC now Rashidi man.

[ffaacc03]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

Both are excellent custom rosters and editors ... both are now considering ratings and tendencies edits ... both have cons and props for quick/season/association modes ... both noticeable enhance the experience when compared to default, in fact there is no comparition at all ... as someone said, it is a matter of preference.

We, the PS3 users, will get them again ... for those who cant remember, we did got a taste of both last year ... thanks to our OS 360 fellows.

[RockDatBeat]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

I personally find Nogster's a bit more useful because he focuses more on tendencies and I'm an association guy. Then I just edit anyone that I feel isn't really rated right.

I use Rashidi's rosters for quick games though as I play against friends a lot.

[bamalam]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

nog also does playbooks/coaches, not sure about rash

[Freshy McFresho]

Re: Nogster's rosters vs Rashidi's rosters?

I download both nogster and rashidi and combine them with DC edits. I combine nogster tendency with rashidi ratings with DC edits equals the best rosters ever. Goddammit first DC now Rashidi man.

put these up on 2k share?