Settings stuck on Rookie when I play offline
 

When I try playing against someone on my console, my account usually stays on whatever setting I choose like for instance I choose All-Madden. When someone else tries changing the difficulty of theirs to All-Madden it seems fine at first. As we get in the game, we notice it reverts back to Rookie, so we are not sure what player he is throwing to since all we see are X's.

I have no idea how to fix this at all

Go to gameplay change the level in player skill then save your profile.

SB_ndboi